Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground
(08-11-2023, 12:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:08 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 11:59 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: It economically owns 88.6% of the club!   That’s Holdings’ intrinsic value!

OK, but would it be correct to say that any debts Holdings has aren't debts of the club and neither should club funds be used to service such debts? 

Also, why would Holdings need to borrow money anyway?

100% correct re your first question. 

No doubt the shareholders of Holdings wanted to raise funds for their own benefit against the security of their investment.  That’s entirely up to them as it’s not taking money out of the underlying investment (Group/Club).  It’s entirely at their own risk, putting their own asset on the line as security.

(08-11-2023, 12:20 PM)MGalea Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:08 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: OK, but would it be correct to say that any debts Holdings has aren't debts of the club and neither should club funds be used to service such debts? 

Also, why would Holdings need to borrow money anyway?

Therefore 2.35% of Holdings = approx 2% of "the club"

Correct, albeit indirectly.

So in summary then, Warmfront can’t come after the club for the £4m+ money that is owed, however Holdings could decide to take money out of the club it majority owns to repay, but the club have no express need to repay it?

However Warmfront could agree to convert their debt into shares and subsequently have a say in the ownership of the club given they’d own % of the holding company that owns 88% of the club?

Essentially either Yunyai will be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership structure, adding a further debt that will need repaying by any potential buyer. or may be motivated to pull yet more money out the club to satisfy their debt?

1.  Warmfront definitely cannot come after Group or Club.  

2. Holdings can’t take any money out of the club that it majority owns because (a) that would be a breach of the MSD loan, and (b) it would be a breach of fiduciary duty by the directors of Group or Club to pay anything to Holdings did that purpose.  Lai knows that people are watching like a hawk for any such attempts, and indeed I think that’s why Lai had no option to use the shares in Holdings as security to get access to cash, because all other routes were closed to him. 

3. Warmfront would not have any significant voice in Holdings if they own even 10% of Holdings, as Yunyai in China would still own 78%. 

4. Yes it would be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership, albeit a tiny immaterial percentage beneath the EFL threshold. But no, there would be no further debt to be repaid on a sale by any party other than those who have borrowed. If Holdings sells the club, then Holdings receives the sale proceeds and needs to settle its debts from those proceeds. They are not liabilities of Group or Club.  They are merely liabilities of Holdings.  That’s their issue, not ours.

With reference to the bit in bold above, the Warmfront loan was taken out in September 2021 before Lai's shenanigans first came to light in June 2022.
Reply
(08-11-2023, 01:42 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 01:00 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Imagine having to do due diligence with these shady fuckers?

It would be a bit like a magicians trick when you ask about a breakdown of any loans / moneys owed. Just when you think it's finished they'd pull another one out of the pocket.

When you think how shrewdly we were run under Peace, It's a travesty what we've become.

A buyer is very likely to be buying a clean company. They’d almost certainly be buying the Jersey intermediate holding company which sits in between Holdings and Group.  They then don’t be remotely concerned about what Holdings might have been up to.

(08-11-2023, 02:00 PM)throstle Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:08 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: OK, but would it be correct to say that any debts Holdings has aren't debts of the club and neither should club funds be used to service such debts? 

Also, why would Holdings need to borrow money anyway?

100% correct re your first question. 

No doubt the shareholders of Holdings wanted to raise funds for their own benefit against the security of their investment.  That’s entirely up to them as it’s not taking money out of the underlying investment (Group/Club).  It’s entirely at their own risk, putting their own asset on the line as security.

(08-11-2023, 12:20 PM)MGalea Wrote: Therefore 2.35% of Holdings = approx 2% of "the club"

Correct, albeit indirectly.

So in summary then, Warmfront can’t come after the club for the £4m+ money that is owed, however Holdings could decide to take money out of the club it majority owns to repay, but the club have no express need to repay it?

However Warmfront could agree to convert their debt into shares and subsequently have a say in the ownership of the club given they’d own % of the holding company that owns 88% of the club?

Essentially either Yunyai will be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership structure, adding a further debt that will need repaying by any potential buyer. or may be motivated to pull yet more money out the club to satisfy their debt?

1.  Warmfront definitely cannot come after Group or Club.  

2. Holdings can’t take any money out of the club that it majority owns because (a) that would be a breach of the MSD loan, and (b) it would be a breach of fiduciary duty by the directors of Group or Club to pay anything to Holdings did that purpose.  Lai knows that people are watching like a hawk for any such attempts, and indeed I think that’s why Lai had no option to use the shares in Holdings as security to get access to cash, because all other routes were closed to him. 

3. Warmfront would not have any significant voice in Holdings if they own even 10% of Holdings, as Yunyai in China would still own 78%. 

4. Yes it would be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership, albeit a tiny immaterial percentage beneath the EFL threshold. But no, there would be no further debt to be repaid on a sale by any party other than those who have borrowed. If Holdings sells the club, then Holdings receives the sale proceeds and needs to settle its debts from those proceeds. They are not liabilities of Group or Club.  They are merely liabilities of Holdings.  That’s their issue, not ours.

With reference to the bit in bold above, the Warmfront loan was taken out in September 2021 before Lai's shenanigans first came to light in June 2022.

Lai & Co will have already known that they should not have been doing what they were doing and could not rely on doing more of the same.  Needed an alternative.
Reply
(08-11-2023, 01:42 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 01:00 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Imagine having to do due diligence with these shady fuckers?

It would be a bit like a magicians trick when you ask about a breakdown of any loans / moneys owed. Just when you think it's finished they'd pull another one out of the pocket.

When you think how shrewdly we were run under Peace, It's a travesty what we've become.

JP started the smoke and mirrors to hide his antics.

Before JP appeared on the scene, it was nice and simple with just West Bromwich Albion Football Club Limited.

He set up West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited in 2004, West Bromwich Albion Group Limited in 2010, dissolved original West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited in 2011 and set up a new West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited in 2013.
Reply
I'm totally lost as to who and what owns who , can somebody do a spreadsheet
Reply
(08-11-2023, 12:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:08 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 11:59 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: It economically owns 88.6% of the club!   That’s Holdings’ intrinsic value!

OK, but would it be correct to say that any debts Holdings has aren't debts of the club and neither should club funds be used to service such debts? 

Also, why would Holdings need to borrow money anyway?

100% correct re your first question. 

No doubt the shareholders of Holdings wanted to raise funds for their own benefit against the security of their investment.  That’s entirely up to them as it’s not taking money out of the underlying investment (Group/Club).  It’s entirely at their own risk, putting their own asset on the line as security.

(08-11-2023, 12:20 PM)MGalea Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:08 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: OK, but would it be correct to say that any debts Holdings has aren't debts of the club and neither should club funds be used to service such debts? 

Also, why would Holdings need to borrow money anyway?

Therefore 2.35% of Holdings = approx 2% of "the club"

Correct, albeit indirectly.

So in summary then, Warmfront can’t come after the club for the £4m+ money that is owed, however Holdings could decide to take money out of the club it majority owns to repay, but the club have no express need to repay it?

However Warmfront could agree to convert their debt into shares and subsequently have a say in the ownership of the club given they’d own % of the holding company that owns 88% of the club?

Essentially either Yunyai will be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership structure, adding a further debt that will need repaying by any potential buyer. or may be motivated to pull yet more money out the club to satisfy their debt?

1.  Warmfront definitely cannot come after Group or Club.  

2. Holdings can’t take any money out of the club that it majority owns because (a) that would be a breach of the MSD loan, and (b) it would be a breach of fiduciary duty by the directors of Group or Club to pay anything to Holdings did that purpose.  Lai knows that people are watching like a hawk for any such attempts, and indeed I think that’s why Lai had no option to use the shares in Holdings as security to get access to cash, because all other routes were closed to him. 

3. Warmfront would not have any significant voice in Holdings if they own even 10% of Holdings, as Yunyai in China would still own 78%. 

4. Yes it would be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership, albeit a tiny immaterial percentage beneath the EFL threshold. But no, there would be no further debt to be repaid on a sale by any party other than those who have borrowed. If Holdings sells the club, then Holdings receives the sale proceeds and needs to settle its debts from those proceeds. They are not liabilities of Group or Club.  They are merely liabilities of Holdings.  That’s their issue, not ours.

Thanks for this Prag - all makes sense.

In conclusion, nothing to really concern ourselves with, other than it may just make it a little more complex to sell the club, but given the network of owners already, it’s hardly likely to put off any buyers.
Reply
(08-11-2023, 02:30 PM)throstle Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 01:42 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 01:00 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Imagine having to do due diligence with these shady fuckers?

It would be a bit like a magicians trick when you ask about a breakdown of any loans / moneys owed. Just when you think it's finished they'd pull another one out of the pocket.

When you think how shrewdly we were run under Peace, It's a travesty what we've become.

JP started the smoke and mirrors to hide his antics.

Before JP appeared on the scene, it was nice and simple with just West Bromwich Albion Football Club Limited.

He set up West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited in 2004, West Bromwich Albion Group Limited in 2010, dissolved original West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited in 2011 and set up a new West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited in 2013.
That's true Throstle, and he left us with a loan unresolved. He wasn't perfect, but I'd have him over these charlatans any day of the week.
Reply
14 pages in, and I've just discovered that the bloke in the thread title died in October 2022.    FFS    Rolleyes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran%C3%A7ois_Chesnais
Reply
(08-11-2023, 02:00 PM)throstle Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:08 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: OK, but would it be correct to say that any debts Holdings has aren't debts of the club and neither should club funds be used to service such debts? 

Also, why would Holdings need to borrow money anyway?

100% correct re your first question. 

No doubt the shareholders of Holdings wanted to raise funds for their own benefit against the security of their investment.  That’s entirely up to them as it’s not taking money out of the underlying investment (Group/Club).  It’s entirely at their own risk, putting their own asset on the line as security.

(08-11-2023, 12:20 PM)MGalea Wrote: Therefore 2.35% of Holdings = approx 2% of "the club"

Correct, albeit indirectly.

So in summary then, Warmfront can’t come after the club for the £4m+ money that is owed, however Holdings could decide to take money out of the club it majority owns to repay, but the club have no express need to repay it?

However Warmfront could agree to convert their debt into shares and subsequently have a say in the ownership of the club given they’d own % of the holding company that owns 88% of the club?

Essentially either Yunyai will be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership structure, adding a further debt that will need repaying by any potential buyer. or may be motivated to pull yet more money out the club to satisfy their debt?

1.  Warmfront definitely cannot come after Group or Club.  

2. Holdings can’t take any money out of the club that it majority owns because (a) that would be a breach of the MSD loan, and (b) it would be a breach of fiduciary duty by the directors of Group or Club to pay anything to Holdings did that purpose.  Lai knows that people are watching like a hawk for any such attempts, and indeed I think that’s why Lai had no option to use the shares in Holdings as security to get access to cash, because all other routes were closed to him. 

3. Warmfront would not have any significant voice in Holdings if they own even 10% of Holdings, as Yunyai in China would still own 78%. 

4. Yes it would be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership, albeit a tiny immaterial percentage beneath the EFL threshold. But no, there would be no further debt to be repaid on a sale by any party other than those who have borrowed. If Holdings sells the club, then Holdings receives the sale proceeds and needs to settle its debts from those proceeds. They are not liabilities of Group or Club.  They are merely liabilities of Holdings.  That’s their issue, not ours.

With reference to the bit in bold above, the Warmfront loan was taken out in September 2021 before Lai's shenanigans first came to light in June 2022.

It was little known, but true, Lai made a failed attempt to take money out of the club just before Xmas 2020. Unfortunately he kept trying until he succeeded. Much credit is due to the minority shareholders for keeping an eye on these crooks.
Reply
(08-11-2023, 02:43 PM)Noibla Wrote: I'm totally lost as to who and what owns who , can somebody do a spreadsheet

Hopefully this will make it easier to understand (Lai is the one right in the middle with the swag bag!):
 [Image: 186937.webp]
Reply
(08-11-2023, 02:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 02:00 PM)throstle Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:42 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-11-2023, 12:21 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: 100% correct re your first question. 

No doubt the shareholders of Holdings wanted to raise funds for their own benefit against the security of their investment.  That’s entirely up to them as it’s not taking money out of the underlying investment (Group/Club).  It’s entirely at their own risk, putting their own asset on the line as security.


Correct, albeit indirectly.

So in summary then, Warmfront can’t come after the club for the £4m+ money that is owed, however Holdings could decide to take money out of the club it majority owns to repay, but the club have no express need to repay it?

However Warmfront could agree to convert their debt into shares and subsequently have a say in the ownership of the club given they’d own % of the holding company that owns 88% of the club?

Essentially either Yunyai will be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership structure, adding a further debt that will need repaying by any potential buyer. or may be motivated to pull yet more money out the club to satisfy their debt?

1.  Warmfront definitely cannot come after Group or Club.  

2. Holdings can’t take any money out of the club that it majority owns because (a) that would be a breach of the MSD loan, and (b) it would be a breach of fiduciary duty by the directors of Group or Club to pay anything to Holdings did that purpose.  Lai knows that people are watching like a hawk for any such attempts, and indeed I think that’s why Lai had no option to use the shares in Holdings as security to get access to cash, because all other routes were closed to him. 

3. Warmfront would not have any significant voice in Holdings if they own even 10% of Holdings, as Yunyai in China would still own 78%. 

4. Yes it would be adding another person of dubious intention to the ownership, albeit a tiny immaterial percentage beneath the EFL threshold. But no, there would be no further debt to be repaid on a sale by any party other than those who have borrowed. If Holdings sells the club, then Holdings receives the sale proceeds and needs to settle its debts from those proceeds. They are not liabilities of Group or Club.  They are merely liabilities of Holdings.  That’s their issue, not ours.

With reference to the bit in bold above, the Warmfront loan was taken out in September 2021 before Lai's shenanigans first came to light in June 2022.

It was little known, but true, Lai made a failed attempt to take money out of the club just before Xmas 2020. Unfortunately he kept trying until he succeeded. Much credit is due to the minority shareholders for keeping an eye on these crooks.

Whilst it is correct to say under point 2 that money cannot be withdrawn without the consent of the debenture holder (MSD), the reality is that MSD would only know when annual accounts are filed, which is up to 9 months after the financial year end. By which time the consortium may well have sold the business. If they do take money out (without consent of the debenture holder), then they have breached the loan covenants. This gives MSD options, but does not necessarily mean MSD would foreclose on the loan.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)