City Ground redevelopment..
(02-12-2020, 01:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 12:13 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 11:25 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 08:46 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-11-2020, 08:15 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: After having to completely shut down parts of the stadium for 2 seasons

The truth is that we hoped to move location and not waste money on the current site. Relegation put the brakes on that. Where it is situated isn't worth it because of restrictions.

Where had we hoped to move?
I haven't a clue tbh. It's all speculation on my part. There's been plenty land become available and built on or reused over recent times. Our current address limits us and I guess if we did change things we'd want to do it full scale with a decent size stadium somewhere else. Do it once more only so to speak. Hence the not bothering to do owt with the current gaff. Despite claims to the contrary, the club has been and still is top table in the running division. They ain't stoopid, naive or risk takers. All of the points made by everyone are true but what's best for the club will always prevail but situations will change.
So 'the truth' is no more than the pixies in your head making a wild baseless guess!
Never have I heard talk of us moving- it's never been mooted. Peace spoke of expanding beyond 30,000 about 10 years ago and then changed his mind. 
The issue is the Halfords being right on Halfords Lane, not allowing expansion there without applications to build over the road etc, with a tunnel underneath. It has less than 4,000 seats now- it's barely championship standard. A normal sized stand there would push us to 30-31,000.

Go on then clever bollox. You explain why we haven't been arsed to do it. The move theory is just my opinion. The facts are facts despite you bleating about not being able to get tickets when normally there are hundreds left.
Sorry to offend, but when you speak of 'the truth' when it is just your opinion then it is totally misleading. 
The facts are seldom the facts on here, they are points of debate. For what it's worth, I think we haven't done it as the club's owners have been unambitious and tight, which is my opinion, not a fact. 
Once again sorry it got your goat, but no one minds the cut and thrust of all things Albion, but admit the things as they are. 
Incidentally, in the last 30 years it's noteworthy that none of the W Mids clubs have moved to a new stadium. Personally, I'd hate us to.
Reply
(02-12-2020, 01:15 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 01:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 12:13 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 11:25 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(02-12-2020, 08:46 AM)Squid Wrote: Where had we hoped to move?
I haven't a clue tbh. It's all speculation on my part. There's been plenty land become available and built on or reused over recent times. Our current address limits us and I guess if we did change things we'd want to do it full scale with a decent size stadium somewhere else. Do it once more only so to speak. Hence the not bothering to do owt with the current gaff. Despite claims to the contrary, the club has been and still is top table in the running division. They ain't stoopid, naive or risk takers. All of the points made by everyone are true but what's best for the club will always prevail but situations will change.
So 'the truth' is no more than the pixies in your head making a wild baseless guess!
Never have I heard talk of us moving- it's never been mooted. Peace spoke of expanding beyond 30,000 about 10 years ago and then changed his mind. 
The issue is the Halfords being right on Halfords Lane, not allowing expansion there without applications to build over the road etc, with a tunnel underneath. It has less than 4,000 seats now- it's barely championship standard. A normal sized stand there would push us to 30-31,000.

Go on then clever bollox. You explain why we haven't been arsed to do it. The move theory is just my opinion. The facts are facts despite you bleating about not being able to get tickets when normally there are hundreds left.
Sorry to offend, but when you speak of 'the truth' when it is just your opinion then it is totally misleading. 
The facts are seldom the facts on here, they are points of debate. For what it's worth, I think we haven't done it as the club's owners have been unambitious and tight, which is my opinion, not a fact. 
Once again sorry it got your goat, but no one minds the cut and thrust of all things Albion, but admit the things as they are. 
Incidentally, in the last 30 years it's noteworthy that none of the W Mids clubs have moved to a new stadium. Personally, I'd hate us to.

Big thumbs up mon. No probs. Get your tickets earlier  Big Grin Tongue
Reply
The plans were laid out at about the time that we got the East stand completed and in fairness old baldy was keen on the idea. Then it became a bit like hard work - the plans were either to build over the Halfords lane or reroute it around the old Hawthorns pub which were both options that were drawn up, the problem comes from the hire depot across the road who have refused to sell (or refused to sell for a reasonable price) apparently / allegedly.
Reply
(02-12-2020, 01:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The plans were laid out at about the time that we got the East stand completed and in fairness old baldy was keen on the idea. Then it became a bit like hard work - the plans were either to build over the Halfords lane or reroute it around the old Hawthorns pub which were both options that were drawn up, the problem comes from the hire depot across the road who have refused to sell (or refused to sell for a reasonable price) apparently / allegedly.

Exactly. Hence my opinion it's not worth spending a penny on that stand until the status quo changes or an alternative site becomes available and we are in the position to be able to afford a move. Mean time we're hardly slumming it and only a few games require a bigger capacity each season. That's what me and my pixies reckon for what it's worth.
Reply
Didn't the club used to own most of the land around it once?
Reply
fwiw - did a stadium tour pre the sheff wed game, and the tour guide said that there were plans to utilise the space in the corner of the brummie (next to the woodman corner) which is not used due to the restricted view, and at  the same time extend that corner.

Wouldn't be surprised if its dependent like so much on where we are next season.
Reply
(02-11-2020, 01:28 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(02-11-2020, 11:37 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.

Exactly.

Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.

Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.

So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.

Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.

Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced  - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom

Remi does the maths on 'ere!

But I'll have a pop... 'Pools works out at £3,750 per seat, and whilst Aachen may have built a ground cheaper you can assume the Liverpool price is more along the lines of what it would cost over here. Official Halford's capacity is currently on 3,773 BTW. Can't really use the East STand to compare costs as it was built 19 years ago and things have gone up a lot since then.

In effect you're looking at a ten year season ticket to cover the build cost (ignoring maintenance) of each seat. That's also excluding the simple fact that the club would probably end up needing to pay a lot more to do something to Halford's Lane (sewers, gas mains, electric, broadband etc...) , they may even have to re-route part of the road, and that could then lead to changes needed at the Academy over the road, etc..., but would assume it would increase costs further. A simple 5,000 expansion would likely cost c£19m, based on Liverpool's costs, which may actually work out lower since they had more seats...add in that it's building on an existing structure & the road and you may well end up almost doubling the costs (based on it cost £16m for them to do Centenary Square in Brum (and that was largely a paving and putting in some nice garden bits and fountains type work...very little vertical stuff)).

I don't think we'd see much change from £30m, for something that may give us 5,000 more capacity which likely would rarely get past half full. *if* we get promoted *and* re-establish ourselves then I would say do it, until then it would be an expense that could impact promotion chances.

£30M-ish

Borrow most of that over 7 to 10 years. 

Wim goowin up, so Nike slogan please.

If you are relegated then your income drops dramatically, and would make servicing that loan difficult. The most you could borrow would be c£21M, and repayments over 7 years would be around £3.5M p.a., which is a lot when your turnover is less than £20M p.a. in the Chump.
Reply
This has turned out to be a very good thread.
Reply
The Halfords belongs in League 1. Should have rebuilt it a long time ago.
Reply
JP once mooted moving towards Wednesbury, possibly Hill Top way, IIRC. I also suspect there may have been some derelict land/business development grants available. Anyway, it didn't happen and Albion put all their efforts into The Hawthorns.
TBF, with the rail, tram and Mway, it ain't a bad site. JP also reckoned we owned a lot of the land going towards the Mway, I suppose he meant the Sandwell Academy buildings we can all see from B'ham Rd.
I believe Albion own much of the land opposite the Halfords entrances. As said by others, the exception being the Hoist Hire people who know they are holding the last ace in the pack. Maybe we should club together and build a new stand around and over the top of 'em!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: