Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
Posts: 2,915
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
Have you looked up selfish yet?
Haha
Posts: 7,473
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
(06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
More people to empty the bins?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-11-2025, 03:14 PM)KRO Wrote: Have you looked up selfish yet?
Haha
Have you looked up the fiscal cliff edges at £50K and £100K? Have you seen that the Higher Rate threshold would be £75-£80K had it risen on trend? Have you looked up the taxation attacks on pretty much anyone who has a defined contribution pension? Have you looked at the Stamp Duty penalty applied to Landlords or the fact that most (not me thank fk) are taxed on rental income, not on profit?
At the same time as pretty much everyone over £40K has been squeezed and squeezed for a decade or more the basic allowance and minimum wage have soared. If you're on the median wage you've pretty much got more money in your pocket than ever before.
The question most people on above average wages are asking is "why bother"?
My plasterer works 9 months of the year otherwise he'd have to register for VAT and increase his prices by 20%. Who does that help? No one.
My sparky works 9 months of the year otherwise his marginal rate of taxation increases to 70%. Who in their right mind would work for 30p in the £1?
I'm sure I don't need to give you the the old 10 men in a pub story do I?
If you disincentivise work and investment, can you be surprised when people don't work and don't invest? And you call it selfish? OK.
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
(06-11-2025, 03:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 03:14 PM)KRO Wrote: Have you looked up selfish yet?
Haha
Have you looked up the fiscal cliff edges at £50K and £100K? Have you seen that the Higher Rate threshold would be £75-£80K had it risen on trend? Have you looked up the taxation attacks on pretty much anyone who has a defined contribution pension? Have you looked at the Stamp Duty penalty applied to Landlords or the fact that most (not me thank fk) are taxed on rental income, not on profit?
At the same time as pretty much everyone over £40K has been squeezed and squeezed for a decade or more the basic allowance and minimum wage have soared. If you're on the median wage you've pretty much got more money in your pocket than ever before.
The question most people on above average wages are asking is "why bother"?
My plasterer works 9 months of the year otherwise he'd have to register for VAT and increase his prices by 20%. Who does that help? No one.
My sparky works 9 months of the year otherwise his marginal rate of taxation increases to 70%. Who in their right mind would work for 30p in the £1?
I'm sure I don't need to give you the the old 10 men in a pub story do I?
If you disincentivise work and investment, can you be surprised when people don't work and don't invest? And you call it selfish? OK.
Cash...... is....... King  .
Posts: 2,915
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
06-11-2025, 03:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2025, 03:39 PM by KRO.)
(06-11-2025, 03:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 03:14 PM)KRO Wrote: Have you looked up selfish yet?
Haha
Have you looked up the fiscal cliff edges at £50K and £100K? Have you seen that the Higher Rate threshold would be £75-£80K had it risen on trend? Have you looked up the taxation attacks on pretty much anyone who has a defined contribution pension? Have you looked at the Stamp Duty penalty applied to Landlords or the fact that most (not me thank fk) are taxed on rental income, not on profit?
At the same time as pretty much everyone over £40K has been squeezed and squeezed for a decade or more the basic allowance and minimum wage have soared. If you're on the median wage you've pretty much got more money in your pocket than ever before.
The question most people on above average wages are asking is "why bother"?
My plasterer works 9 months of the year otherwise he'd have to register for VAT and increase his prices by 20%. Who does that help? No one.
My sparky works 9 months of the year otherwise his marginal rate of taxation increases to 70%. Who in their right mind would work for 30p in the £1?
I'm sure I don't need to give you the the old 10 men in a pub story do I?
If you disincentivise work and investment, can you be surprised when people don't work and don't invest? And you call it selfish? OK.
So people on 40k a year have been squeezed and minimum wage has soared you say.
Incredible then that those on 40k plus aren’t quitting and lapping up the benefits of being on the minimum wage then isn’t it?
Btw I know quite a few who work for free. You know doing stuff for others. Something you don’t seem to mention
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
Proth often mentions enlightened self interest and, as ever, it means the opposite of what he seems to think it means.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.
But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others.
And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess.
You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Proth takes a fair bit of stick on here, and in fairness much of it is deserved, but him and his kind aren’t really the issue here. I agree with a lot of what he says and wants, despite being far more socialist in my political leanings ideologically, but realising the need in our present society for some capitalism and entrepreneurialism.
The issue is the small percentage with tens of millions of pounds tied up in land, property and sitting in trusts where it’s failing to help those that need it. The inherited wealth passed along lineages is what needs to be taxed, just because you’ve had the good fortune to be born into wealth doesn’t make you entitled to it.
Tough IHT on large sums, land value taxes and wealth taxes to redistribute what the top 10-15% do not need but merely want is key. Nobody needs tens of millions of pounds.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
06-11-2025, 04:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2025, 04:19 PM by Fido.)
There’s only one thing worse than inherited upper class wealth and that’s working class wealth.
|