Kneecap
(06-30-2025, 09:59 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Why do papers like the Telegraph, Mail etc get so upset by this kind of thing

For commercial reasons. Clickbait.

However, it does concern me that there is certain proportion of our population who fail to see the irony of chanting "death to the IDF" (national service is compulsory in Israel, so essentially all adult Israelis) whilst behind the type of security fence that could have wholly prevented the massacre at the Nova festival.

I wonder if there'll be any cognitive dissonance when the white middle aged middle class professionals return to work this week with their Jewish colleagues. I doubt it. It's too embedded in parts of our society.
Reply
About the same level of concern as people labelling whole nations (of mainly brown people) “the armpit of the world” and being comfortable with it. The same people who’s only response to concern for genocide to brand it as “anti-Semitic”

Do you worry about how comfortable they are in the company of colleagues, neighbours and fellow human beings?

Or doesn’t that matter or count?
Reply
(06-30-2025, 10:49 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: About the same level of concern as people labelling whole nations (of mainly brown people) “the armpit of the world” and being comfortable with it. The same people who’s only response to concern for genocide to brand it as “anti-Semitic”

Do you worry about how comfortable they are in the company of colleagues, neighbours and fellow human beings?

Or doesn’t that matter or count?

When did I do that?

When I refer to the armpit of the world I'm referring to the despots who throw homosexual men off buildings, witness the massacre of Christians and other religious / ethnic minorities at prayer, don't even pay lip service to the concept of sexual equality and indulge in decades of repression and summary justice. Iran directly and via its proxies (and Syria under Assad) have killed far more Arabs than Israel has. If you have a better description for countries like that I'd be happy to use it instead. Just let me know.

As it stands the Israeli government's behaviour in Gaza and elsewhere is beyond the pale. In cases lowering its behaviour to the level of Hamas. Israel is always held to a higher level of accountability than its neighbours - but that is the price of being a democracy I suppose. I stand with those Israelis, Palestinians, Syrians & Iranians who genuinely want an end to hostilities. It's a pity they're not in power.
Reply
Israel may be held to higher levels of accountability in literature and conversations/attitudes but it certainly isn’t in its military and political realities and actions, which is more important.

You can’t reference all the concerns you have above and then never appear to have anything to say about a military that’s routinely shooting dead people as they try to seek food and basic goods every day. Imagine if that was any other nation?

Otherwise, fair post and with you on the last part
Reply
(06-30-2025, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: When did I do that?

When I refer to the armpit of the world I'm referring to the despots who throw homosexual men off buildings, witness the massacre of Christians and other religious / ethnic minorities at prayer, don't even pay lip service to the concept of sexual equality and indulge in decades of repression and summary justice. Iran directly and via its proxies (and Syria under Assad) have killed far more Arabs than Israel has. If you have a better description for countries like that I'd be happy to use it instead. Just let me know.

As it stands the Israeli government's behaviour in Gaza and elsewhere is beyond the pale. In cases lowering its behaviour to the level of Hamas. Israel is always held to a higher level of accountability than its neighbours - but that is the price of being a democracy I suppose. I stand with those Israelis, Palestinians, Syrians & Iranians who genuinely want an end to hostilities. It's a pity they're not in power.

Yep, fair enough.

For all the chat on the Glastonbury thread, it's clear that Bob Vylan has taken the wording of his protest too far. I don't think anyone would stand in the way of pointing out the realities of what is happening in Gaza, pointing out the hypocrisy of many who claim not to care, or to support Israel but Saturday turned into a competition to be as outrageous as possible. In which case, sadly, the real losers are the people who's plight you're trying to raise awareness of as many more moderately (but fair) minded people will switch off to it.
Reply
(06-30-2025, 11:51 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Israel may be held to higher levels of accountability in literature and conversations/attitudes but it certainly isn’t in its military and political realities and actions, which is more important.

You can’t reference all the concerns you have above and then never appear to have anything to say about a military that’s routinely shooting dead people as they try to seek food and basic goods every day. Imagine if that was any other nation?

Otherwise, fair post and with you on the last part

It's horrific and the West is complicit. Is that enough?

(06-30-2025, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: For all the chat on the Glastonbury thread, it's clear that Bob Vylan has taken the wording of his protest too far. I don't think anyone would stand in the way of pointing out the realities of what is happening in Gaza, pointing out the hypocrisy of many who claim not to care, or to support Israel but Saturday turned into a competition to be as outrageous as possible. In which case, sadly, the real losers are the people who's plight you're trying to raise awareness of as many more moderately (but fair) minded people will switch off to it.

Indeed. 

There is something very nasty in the popular narrative, almost a nod and wink that certain speech is OK. And that is very deeply embedded I'm afraid.

I don't remember Festival goers being egged on in chants to kill white South African Policemen during the 1980s when the anti-apartheid movement was at its height.
Reply
Fucking hell, look at us all, agreeing etc.
Reply
(06-30-2025, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2025, 09:59 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Why do papers like the Telegraph, Mail etc get so upset by this kind of thing

For commercial reasons. Clickbait.

However, it does concern me that there is certain proportion of our population who fail to see the irony of chanting "death to the IDF" (national service is compulsory in Israel, so essentially all adult Israelis) whilst behind the type of security fence that could have wholly prevented the massacre at the Nova festival.

I wonder if there'll be any cognitive dissonance when the white middle aged middle class professionals return to work this week with their Jewish colleagues. I doubt it. It's too embedded in parts of our society.

And you think Bob Vylan did what they did for strictly non commercial reasons?
Reply
They knew exactly what they were doing. That's showbiz.
Reply
(06-30-2025, 01:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: They knew exactly what they were doing. That's showbiz.

I’m not sure they had thought it through quite as much as you’d think

Idiotic
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: