Hegazi going......
(10-25-2020, 10:08 PM)Sliced Wrote: I genuinely can't believe we've done this. It's mental. We're talking about having to wrap our 36 year old centre back in cotton wool because our other options aren't good enough based on 180 minutes of football. Against Brentford he looked fine but our CB partnership conceded two. I remember in the first couple of games how some were talking about "Krychkowiak oozes class" and "he's just one step ahead of the rest".

It's two games. Maybe Ivanovic will be good enough but can he really play every week?! What if he loses form. Bartley and Ajayi were an ok partnership at CHAMP level. In the Prem they will be torn apart.

I've been labelled a happy clapper before, but this decision is absolutely ridiculous. When we're shipping 5 again I won't be thinking "well our defence is fucked but that's ok, we got our highest earner off the wage bill"

He wanted to go. Should we keep a player that wanted to leave?
Reply
(10-25-2020, 10:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:08 PM)Sliced Wrote: I genuinely can't believe we've done this. It's mental. We're talking about having to wrap our 36 year old centre back in cotton wool because our other options aren't good enough based on 180 minutes of football. Against Brentford he looked fine but our CB partnership conceded two. I remember in the first couple of games how some were talking about "Krychkowiak oozes class" and "he's just one step ahead of the rest".

It's two games. Maybe Ivanovic will be good enough but can he really play every week?! What if he loses form. Bartley and Ajayi were an ok partnership at CHAMP level. In the Prem they will be torn apart.

I've been labelled a happy clapper before, but this decision is absolutely ridiculous. When we're shipping 5 again I won't be thinking "well our defence is fucked but that's ok, we got our highest earner off the wage bill"

He wanted to go because the Saudi club, who've been after him for years offered him a ton more money. Should we keep a player that wanted to leave?
I've expanded your argument.
Reply
(10-25-2020, 10:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:08 PM)Sliced Wrote: I genuinely can't believe we've done this. It's mental. We're talking about having to wrap our 36 year old centre back in cotton wool because our other options aren't good enough based on 180 minutes of football. Against Brentford he looked fine but our CB partnership conceded two. I remember in the first couple of games how some were talking about "Krychkowiak oozes class" and "he's just one step ahead of the rest". 

It's two games. Maybe Ivanovic will be good enough but can he really play every week?! What if he loses form. Bartley and Ajayi were an ok partnership at CHAMP level. In the Prem they will be torn apart.

I've been labelled a happy clapper before, but this decision is absolutely ridiculous. When we're shipping 5 again I won't be thinking "well our defence is fucked but that's ok, we got our highest earner off the wage bill"

He wanted to go. Should we keep a player that wanted to leave?

Yes. He was under contract. Players who want to leave continue to play for the team they are under contract for all the time. There was nothing to suggest he was a problem from his performance v Burnley
.



By that logic if Pereira has a cracking couple of months and one of the big teams comes in for him in January should we just let him go if he decides he wants to leave?

The answer is obviously no. It's about what's best for us.
Reply
I hear that Bilic was told to cut the wage bill. We are operating on a slightly bigger budget but 75k off the wage bill is good news for the directors

We have by far the smallest wage bill in the League
Reply
(10-25-2020, 10:35 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:08 PM)Sliced Wrote: I genuinely can't believe we've done this. It's mental. We're talking about having to wrap our 36 year old centre back in cotton wool because our other options aren't good enough based on 180 minutes of football. Against Brentford he looked fine but our CB partnership conceded two. I remember in the first couple of games how some were talking about "Krychkowiak oozes class" and "he's just one step ahead of the rest". 

It's two games. Maybe Ivanovic will be good enough but can he really play every week?! What if he loses form. Bartley and Ajayi were an ok partnership at CHAMP level. In the Prem they will be torn apart.

I've been labelled a happy clapper before, but this decision is absolutely ridiculous. When we're shipping 5 again I won't be thinking "well our defence is fucked but that's ok, we got our highest earner off the wage bill"

He wanted to go. Should we keep a player that wanted to leave?

Yes. He was under contract. Players who want to leave continue to play for the team they are under contract for all the time. There was nothing to suggest he was a problem from his performance v Burnley
.



By that logic if Pereira has a cracking couple of months and one of the big teams comes in for him in January should we just let him go if he decides he want's to leave?

It's about what's best for us

Berahino, Ferguson, Dawson...the list of players that we’ve kept on beyond their wishes. It doesn’t work. He wanted to go last year when they came in for him, but we kept him and he never made a fuss. Doing the same again to him this time around, he wouldn’t have been happy. We also don’t know that the offer was on the table until after the Burnley game.
Reply
I dont necessarily have an issue with selling him, as i said early in the thread. But the more i think about it the more i think something doesnt add up.

We now know he could have gone in Jan but Slav was against it.
Hegazi clearly wanted to go. Fair play, he stayed and didnt sulk like some have in the past.
The Arabian club were clearly still interested.
He didnt play while the transfer window was open. We were told injury, but now i think this was porky pies and would indicate they expected him to go.
Window shuts, he plays against Burnley.
Slav says he is staying.
Less than a week later he's sold, with no prospect of a replacement.

So either the offer was increased to a level we couldnt ignore, or something else has occurred that has forced our hand.

Either way it is strange timing that only weakens us. It may also piss the manager off. I now can only imagine the relationship between Slav and Dowling/Ken being decidely frosty. Right now i wouldnt blame Slav for walking away. He is pissing in the wind here and clearly will not be able to build a competitive squad. He may want to go whilst his reputation is still intact.
Reply
(10-25-2020, 10:38 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:35 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:08 PM)Sliced Wrote: I genuinely can't believe we've done this. It's mental. We're talking about having to wrap our 36 year old centre back in cotton wool because our other options aren't good enough based on 180 minutes of football. Against Brentford he looked fine but our CB partnership conceded two. I remember in the first couple of games how some were talking about "Krychkowiak oozes class" and "he's just one step ahead of the rest". 

It's two games. Maybe Ivanovic will be good enough but can he really play every week?! What if he loses form. Bartley and Ajayi were an ok partnership at CHAMP level. In the Prem they will be torn apart.

I've been labelled a happy clapper before, but this decision is absolutely ridiculous. When we're shipping 5 again I won't be thinking "well our defence is fucked but that's ok, we got our highest earner off the wage bill"

He wanted to go. Should we keep a player that wanted to leave?

Yes. He was under contract. Players who want to leave continue to play for the team they are under contract for all the time. There was nothing to suggest he was a problem from his performance v Burnley
.



By that logic if Pereira has a cracking couple of months and one of the big teams comes in for him in January should we just let him go if he decides he want's to leave?

It's about what's best for us

Berating, Ferguson, Dawson...the list of players that we’ve kept on beyond their wishes. It doesn’t work. He wanted to go last year when they came in for him, but we kept him and he never made a fuss. Doing the same again to him this time around, he wouldn’t have been happy.

You've said it doesn't work but in the next sentence said that we've already kept Hegazi when he wants to leave for over a year and he hasn't kicked up a fuss, so clearly it's not that much of a problem. Of course there are some bad eggs that down tools but Hegazi hasn't, and a lot don't.

If behind the scenes Hegazi is kicking up a fuss, which doesn't seem to be the case at all, and he's replaceable then you get rid of him in January or over the summer when there's an opportunity to get someone else in. Not the week after he's been put back in the team and our centre backs go from looking like headless chickens to a solid pairing. It's ridiculous.
Reply
(10-25-2020, 10:44 PM)MrFizz Wrote: I dont necessarily have an issue with selling him, as i said early in the thread. But the more i think about it the more i think something doesnt add up.

We now know he could have gone in Jan but Slav was against it.
Hegazi clearly wanted to go. Fair play, he stayed and didnt sulk like some have in the past.
The Arabian club were clearly still interested.
He didnt play while the transfer window was open. We were told injury, but now i think this was porky pies and would  indicate they expected him to go.
Window shuts, he plays against Burnley.
Slav says he is staying.
Less than a week later he's sold, with no prospect of a replacement.

So either the offer was increased to a level we couldnt ignore, or something else has occurred that has forced our hand.

Either way it is strange timing that only weakens us. It may also piss the manager off. I now can only imagine the relationship between Slav and Dowling/Ken being decidely frosty. Right now i wouldnt blame Slav for walking away. He is pissing in the wind here and clearly will not be able to build a competitive squad. He may want to go whilst his reputation is still intact.

Good post.

Said a million times (but I'm being negative) that we aren't competitive. A piss poor transfer window has seen us add an unproven forward to a Championship squad. 

We'll see what happens with Slav but if the club were that desperate to hire and keep him they have a strange way of showing it!
Reply
I will keep my gob shut at present as there’s two much negativity at present, we’re six matches in out of the bottom 3 but still the negativity continues I wonder how them bottom 3 teams fans feel.
Reply
(10-25-2020, 10:38 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:35 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:24 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-25-2020, 10:08 PM)Sliced Wrote: I genuinely can't believe we've done this. It's mental. We're talking about having to wrap our 36 year old centre back in cotton wool because our other options aren't good enough based on 180 minutes of football. Against Brentford he looked fine but our CB partnership conceded two. I remember in the first couple of games how some were talking about "Krychkowiak oozes class" and "he's just one step ahead of the rest". 

It's two games. Maybe Ivanovic will be good enough but can he really play every week?! What if he loses form. Bartley and Ajayi were an ok partnership at CHAMP level. In the Prem they will be torn apart.

I've been labelled a happy clapper before, but this decision is absolutely ridiculous. When we're shipping 5 again I won't be thinking "well our defence is fucked but that's ok, we got our highest earner off the wage bill"

He wanted to go. Should we keep a player that wanted to leave?

Yes. He was under contract. Players who want to leave continue to play for the team they are under contract for all the time. There was nothing to suggest he was a problem from his performance v Burnley
.



By that logic if Pereira has a cracking couple of months and one of the big teams comes in for him in January should we just let him go if he decides he want's to leave?

It's about what's best for us

Berahino, Ferguson, Dawson...the list of players that we’ve kept on beyond their wishes. It doesn’t work. He wanted to go last year when they came in for him, but we kept him and he never made a fuss. Doing the same again to him this time around, he wouldn’t have been happy. We also don’t know that the offer was on the table until after the Burnley game.

Slav's 'he's going nowhere' was just a bluff to get the Saudi's to cough up. 

He's never been part of Slav's plans and only played as Ajayi and O'shea were away on international duty not as part of some grand master-plan. 

We now have the money for a marquee bosman signing as I've telling yis all summer.  Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: