Johnstone
Illan Meslier. Wow. What a potentially outstanding keeper. When talent meets opportunity. He’s one year older than Josh Griffiths but similar build. All young, talented keepers need is an opportunity IMo
Reply
(09-27-2020, 12:58 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:43 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: The first goal is because his weight is on his wrong foot. He gambled on the shot going to his left and it didn’t.  Had he not he’d have probably made a comfortable save.  I’d put that down to goalkeeper error.

He didn’t make a single save or claim a cross that you wouldn’t expect any first choice keeper at 91 other clubs. 

The 3rd?  It’s not the first time he’s palmed back into play, in fact it’s only been a week since the last time he did it.  Stuart Naylor did it all the time.  Blame the defenders for not reacting? Sure, but forwards all round the world tend to react quicker in those situations.  I wouldn’t put the entire fault of the goal on his shoulders though.  Ffs sake Kanu!

Goalkeeper errors are always highlighted much more because invariably it leads to a goal and it’s the only influence they have on a game.  A defender may head the ball away 20 times in a game and miss the 21st. 

I’ve said it before when it’s reactionary he’s fine, as soon as he has to think or make a decision it goes to shit.  He’s part of the reason we’re conceding, not the only reason.  A better keeper would have less saves to make as they’d organise the defence better.  And to an extent a better defender may make SJs job easier.  Given we’re not changing Johnstone we’d better hope that Ivanovic is the answer.

For those that keep count I’d say his +/- on points is currently sitting on -2 for the season.

We’d have won the game without the first going in.

He was in the right place had Livermore closed down Mount, instead he skips past him and finds space to get a shot off before SJ can readjust... for me the blame for that goal lies with Furlong for failing to pick up Azpilicueta and then Livermore for not taking the man... 

I agree the third goal needed a stronger hand, but the ball should never have got to that point. Townsend should have been stronger, HRK should have cleared it, and O’Shea switched off letting Abraham get goal side, and then failed to react when SJ pushed the ball out.

Given goalkeepers are usually the final piece in any goal going in, it’s easy to attribute blame to them, but there are far more guilty parties in all 3 goals than Johnstone. He could have done a little better on the third, but chances are with Oshea being where he was, any stop would have fallen to Abraham.

Neither of those goals are mistakes to SJ, the fault lies far further down the move.

I think you're missing the point. Nobody is expecting him to make unbelievable saves every time a shot comes in. What we do expect is him to save the ones he should be saving. He's there to make them as the last line of defence because no matter how good our defence is shots will still come in.

As for blaming Furlong for the second ffs. He was fouled by Azpilicueta in the Chelsea half and busted a gut just to get back, hence why Livermore was filling both spaces and why Mount was able to get a 30yd, yes 30yd, shot away.

The third one I don't blame him particularly for the save. The weak punch to a Chelsea player shortly before and Kanus pathetic clearance were more culpable
Reply
With Palmer and Griffiths coming through why spend money on an area that isn't a massive issue.

Despite what it may seem I'm not a fan of Johnstone, however I get tired of the almost delight some people have in his shortcomings.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 01:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Palmer and Griffiths coming through why spend money on an area that isn't a massive issue.

Despite what it may seem  I'm not a fan of Johnstone, however I get tired of the almost delight some people have in his shortcomings.

I said this last night but was shot down by Duffers. I think the club (Dowling) see Griffiths who is 19, as a genuine generational talent. He could be our No.1 next year. He’s only one year younger than the Leeds GK.

It’s why we only signed Button on a 2 year deal. Johnstone only has 2 years left too. So come next Summer both will be down to 1.

I hope Slav is brave and genuinely believes in Griffiths.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 01:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Palmer and Griffiths coming through why spend money on an area that isn't a massive issue.

Despite what it may seem  I'm not a fan of Johnstone, however I get tired of the almost delight some people have in his shortcomings.

No delight from me Birdy. I hate it, it's been a problem for 2 years yet he gets a free ride every game. Can't understand it.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 01:15 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 01:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Palmer and Griffiths coming through why spend money on an area that isn't a massive issue.

Despite what it may seem  I'm not a fan of Johnstone, however I get tired of the almost delight some people have in his shortcomings.

No delight from me Birdy. I hate it, it's been a problem for 2 years yet he gets a free ride every game. Can't understand it.

Free ride???

Have you read this bored after any match?
Reply
He gets slated e very match even before kick off in the warm up .
Reply
(09-27-2020, 01:05 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:58 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:43 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: The first goal is because his weight is on his wrong foot. He gambled on the shot going to his left and it didn’t.  Had he not he’d have probably made a comfortable save.  I’d put that down to goalkeeper error.

He didn’t make a single save or claim a cross that you wouldn’t expect any first choice keeper at 91 other clubs. 

The 3rd?  It’s not the first time he’s palmed back into play, in fact it’s only been a week since the last time he did it.  Stuart Naylor did it all the time.  Blame the defenders for not reacting? Sure, but forwards all round the world tend to react quicker in those situations.  I wouldn’t put the entire fault of the goal on his shoulders though.  Ffs sake Kanu!

Goalkeeper errors are always highlighted much more because invariably it leads to a goal and it’s the only influence they have on a game.  A defender may head the ball away 20 times in a game and miss the 21st. 

I’ve said it before when it’s reactionary he’s fine, as soon as he has to think or make a decision it goes to shit.  He’s part of the reason we’re conceding, not the only reason.  A better keeper would have less saves to make as they’d organise the defence better.  And to an extent a better defender may make SJs job easier.  Given we’re not changing Johnstone we’d better hope that Ivanovic is the answer.

For those that keep count I’d say his +/- on points is currently sitting on -2 for the season.

We’d have won the game without the first going in.

He was in the right place had Livermore closed down Mount, instead he skips past him and finds space to get a shot off before SJ can readjust... for me the blame for that goal lies with Furlong for failing to pick up Azpilicueta and then Livermore for not taking the man... 

I agree the third goal needed a stronger hand, but the ball should never have got to that point. Townsend should have been stronger, HRK should have cleared it, and O’Shea switched off letting Abraham get goal side, and then failed to react when SJ pushed the ball out.

Given goalkeepers are usually the final piece in any goal going in, it’s easy to attribute blame to them, but there are far more guilty parties in all 3 goals than Johnstone. He could have done a little better on the third, but chances are with Oshea being where he was, any stop would have fallen to Abraham.

Neither of those goals are mistakes to SJ, the fault lies far further down the move.

I think you're missing the point. Nobody is expecting him to make unbelievable saves every time a shot comes in. What we do expect is him to save the ones he should be saving. He's there to make them as the last line of defence because no matter how good our defence is shots will still come in.

As for blaming Furlong for the second ffs. He was fouled by Azpilicueta in the Chelsea half and busted a gut just to get back, hence why Livermore was filling both spaces and why Mount was able to get a 30yd, yes 30yd, shot away.

The third one I don't blame him particularly for the save. The weak punch to a Chelsea player shortly before and Kanus pathetic clearance were more culpable

We’re never going to agree Billy. You dislike Johnstone and want him to fail, I appreciate he’s not the best but he’s better than most think. Not much point carrying on.

Birdmon is there a way to block any thread that contains Johnstone bashing? Big Grin
Reply
(09-27-2020, 01:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 01:05 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:58 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:43 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: The first goal is because his weight is on his wrong foot. He gambled on the shot going to his left and it didn’t.  Had he not he’d have probably made a comfortable save.  I’d put that down to goalkeeper error.

He didn’t make a single save or claim a cross that you wouldn’t expect any first choice keeper at 91 other clubs. 

The 3rd?  It’s not the first time he’s palmed back into play, in fact it’s only been a week since the last time he did it.  Stuart Naylor did it all the time.  Blame the defenders for not reacting? Sure, but forwards all round the world tend to react quicker in those situations.  I wouldn’t put the entire fault of the goal on his shoulders though.  Ffs sake Kanu!

Goalkeeper errors are always highlighted much more because invariably it leads to a goal and it’s the only influence they have on a game.  A defender may head the ball away 20 times in a game and miss the 21st. 

I’ve said it before when it’s reactionary he’s fine, as soon as he has to think or make a decision it goes to shit.  He’s part of the reason we’re conceding, not the only reason.  A better keeper would have less saves to make as they’d organise the defence better.  And to an extent a better defender may make SJs job easier.  Given we’re not changing Johnstone we’d better hope that Ivanovic is the answer.

For those that keep count I’d say his +/- on points is currently sitting on -2 for the season.

We’d have won the game without the first going in.

He was in the right place had Livermore closed down Mount, instead he skips past him and finds space to get a shot off before SJ can readjust... for me the blame for that goal lies with Furlong for failing to pick up Azpilicueta and then Livermore for not taking the man... 

I agree the third goal needed a stronger hand, but the ball should never have got to that point. Townsend should have been stronger, HRK should have cleared it, and O’Shea switched off letting Abraham get goal side, and then failed to react when SJ pushed the ball out.

Given goalkeepers are usually the final piece in any goal going in, it’s easy to attribute blame to them, but there are far more guilty parties in all 3 goals than Johnstone. He could have done a little better on the third, but chances are with Oshea being where he was, any stop would have fallen to Abraham.

Neither of those goals are mistakes to SJ, the fault lies far further down the move.

I think you're missing the point. Nobody is expecting him to make unbelievable saves every time a shot comes in. What we do expect is him to save the ones he should be saving. He's there to make them as the last line of defence because no matter how good our defence is shots will still come in.

As for blaming Furlong for the second ffs. He was fouled by Azpilicueta in the Chelsea half and busted a gut just to get back, hence why Livermore was filling both spaces and why Mount was able to get a 30yd, yes 30yd, shot away.

The third one I don't blame him particularly for the save. The weak punch to a Chelsea player shortly before and Kanus pathetic clearance were more culpable

We’re never going to agree Billy. You dislike Johnstone and want him to fail, I appreciate he’s not the best but he’s better than most think. Not much point carrying on.

Birdmon is there a way to block any thread that contains Johnstone bashing? Big Grin

I don't want him to fail at all..I've never said that . I hope from the next match he actually becomes the keeper he probably has the potential to be. But after 2 years making the same mistakes, not developing , not helping his defence, it's time he took some time on the bench. Like I say stick Button in for a few games can't do any worse and it might make Johnstone think.
Reply
He's not good enough, we all know that but us Chump sides get promoted with a vast majority who will struggle.

For me, he's been okay. Enough to prove to me that we'd be better strengthening in other areas and taking the risk with him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: