Johnstone
(09-27-2020, 11:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:00 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:17 AM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:09 AM)billybassett Wrote: Gave him praise last week at Everton and he has made some blinding saves over the 2 years.. A goalkeeper can make a 10pt swing on a season. Ask Lampard about Kepa, ask Klopp about Mignolet. He's a 6'2 keeper that plays 5'9 , no comms, little foot movement. Give Button a go and let's see if Johnson really is our best keeper

Bang on

Surprised to see you calling for Button here Manc.

I don’t think Johnstone did anything wrong yesterday. We lack a leader at the back, but that’s not just down to him, a more organised back line would help immeasurably. We just don’t seem to have that desire across the back line to get a head on the ball or the no nonsense approach to getting rid... take HRK’s feeble clearance at the death yesterday.

The lack of an aerial leader at the back is putting a lot more pressure on SJ to come for balls when he’s just not good at that.

From what I’ve seen of Button is he comes off his line more, but doesn’t have the reactions or the agility of SJ.... I mean Grealish goes down faster than Button.

A man you've seen play just twice is now not good enough to be given a chance to show how good/bad he is but a keeper I've watched for 2 yrs and nigh on 90 matches I'm not supposed to have an opinion on and say is a liability. He's the only thing that's not been changed in a defence that's conceded 10s of goals in 2years.

Mignolet played behind Van Dyke and was still garbage.

You ask for an aerial leader - Bartley was talking all the way through that game yesterday. The only time Johnson did really come out he punched Bartley mostly and the ball dropped in our box. Useless.

That’s not what I’m saying at all, I’m saying I’ve not seen Johnstone do anything to deserve being dropped yet. Which of the goals we’ve conceded this season should he have done better for? He is yet to cost us a goal... meanwhile, in his 2 appearances so far I’ve seen nothing from Button that makes me think we’ve got a budding Buffon waiting to usurp Johnstone from the bench.

I get that older football fans want to see goalie come and catch a ball when it comes into the box, but how many still do? Teams defend deeper at set pieces now, keepers are told to stay on their line, and players no longer mark the post. It’s all about cutting a delivery out before it makes it into the danger zone, instead of letting it into the danger zone hoping the keeper claims it.  Ever find yourself bemoaning corners not beating the first man anymore?! It’s how teams defend them (unless Phillips is taking them, because he is garbage).

I really do not know why people let Johnstone’s presence in our team annoy them so much. He’s probably 5th or 6th down the list of players that need replacing.

He's cost us one last night imho.

As for your analysis of how team's defend now I couldn't disagree more. Just look at how Guardiola and Klopp defend set pieces, they are high and pressing up with their goalkeepers barking at them to keep their line. As soon as any 6yd box becomes filled with players anything can happen when you've got a 5'5" keeper
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:20 AM)The liquidator Wrote: We wouldn't pay the money to get a decent replacement in ......there is your problem.

I suppose...

SJ is good enough for where we sit. He wasn't our worst player yesterday, and consistently isn't. So why sign a replacement for him when there are bigger gaps to fill, and he isn't doing a bad job all-round. 

And if it's a money thing, why didn't you say, rather than pick on the player; as if it's his fault he's not Foster. I'm sure he's trying to be!

Yes Gareth bale earns over a million a fortnight. I'm sure Messi does too. It would be lovely to mix in those circles but right now I couldn't care. These guys really are slapping God in the face, at a time billions face poverty, intercontinental airlines are facing extinction and banks are actually paying us to borrow from them. It really isn't the time to spend a king's ransom on the next decent-looking lanky stopper that comes along, when we have 3. A striker would be far more use.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 12:08 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:20 AM)The liquidator Wrote: We wouldn't pay the money to get a decent replacement in ......there is your problem.

I suppose...

SJ is good enough for where we sit. He wasn't our worst player yesterday, and consistently isn't. So why sign a replacement for him when there are bigger gaps to fill, and he isn't doing a bad job all-round. 

And if it's a money thing, why didn't you say, rather than pick on the player; as if it's his fault he's not Foster. I'm sure he's trying to be!

Yes Gareth bale earns over a million a fortnight. I'm sure Messi does too. It would be lovely to mix in those circles but right now I couldn't care. These guys really are slapping God in the face, at a time billions face poverty, intercontinental airlines are facing extinction and banks are actually paying us to borrow from them. It really isn't the time to spend a king's ransom on the next decent-looking lanky stopper that comes along, when we have 3. A striker would be far more use.

Spot on.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:43 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:00 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:17 AM)MancBaggie Wrote: Bang on

Surprised to see you calling for Button here Manc.

I don’t think Johnstone did anything wrong yesterday. We lack a leader at the back, but that’s not just down to him, a more organised back line would help immeasurably. We just don’t seem to have that desire across the back line to get a head on the ball or the no nonsense approach to getting rid... take HRK’s feeble clearance at the death yesterday.

The lack of an aerial leader at the back is putting a lot more pressure on SJ to come for balls when he’s just not good at that.

From what I’ve seen of Button is he comes off his line more, but doesn’t have the reactions or the agility of SJ.... I mean Grealish goes down faster than Button.

A man you've seen play just twice is now not good enough to be given a chance to show how good/bad he is but a keeper I've watched for 2 yrs and nigh on 90 matches I'm not supposed to have an opinion on and say is a liability. He's the only thing that's not been changed in a defence that's conceded 10s of goals in 2years.

Mignolet played behind Van Dyke and was still garbage.

You ask for an aerial leader - Bartley was talking all the way through that game yesterday. The only time Johnson did really come out he punched Bartley mostly and the ball dropped in our box. Useless.

That’s not what I’m saying at all, I’m saying I’ve not seen Johnstone do anything to deserve being dropped yet. Which of the goals we’ve conceded this season should he have done better for? He is yet to cost us a goal... meanwhile, in his 2 appearances so far I’ve seen nothing from Button that makes me think we’ve got a budding Buffon waiting to usurp Johnstone from the bench.

I get that older football fans want to see goalie come and catch a ball when it comes into the box, but how many still do? Teams defend deeper at set pieces now, keepers are told to stay on their line, and players no longer mark the post. It’s all about cutting a delivery out before it makes it into the danger zone, instead of letting it into the danger zone hoping the keeper claims it.  Ever find yourself bemoaning corners not beating the first man anymore?! It’s how teams defend them (unless Phillips is taking them, because he is garbage).

I really do not know why people let Johnstone’s presence in our team annoy them so much. He’s probably 5th or 6th down the list of players that need replacing.

He's cost us one last night imho.

As for your analysis of how team's defend now I couldn't disagree more. Just look at how Guardiola and Klopp defend set pieces, they are high and pressing up with their goalkeepers barking at them to keep their line. As soon as any 6yd box becomes filled with players anything can happen when you've got a 5'5" keeper

Which one did he cost us yesterday? Absolutely none of those were his fault, only someone with an agenda would entertain that thought. 

Always good to use Guardiola and Klopp as an example of how all teams defend, with arguably the best CBs and GKs in the league! Also, almost half of the goals Man City concede come from set pieces....
Reply
(09-27-2020, 12:16 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:43 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:00 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Surprised to see you calling for Button here Manc.

I don’t think Johnstone did anything wrong yesterday. We lack a leader at the back, but that’s not just down to him, a more organised back line would help immeasurably. We just don’t seem to have that desire across the back line to get a head on the ball or the no nonsense approach to getting rid... take HRK’s feeble clearance at the death yesterday.

The lack of an aerial leader at the back is putting a lot more pressure on SJ to come for balls when he’s just not good at that.

From what I’ve seen of Button is he comes off his line more, but doesn’t have the reactions or the agility of SJ.... I mean Grealish goes down faster than Button.

A man you've seen play just twice is now not good enough to be given a chance to show how good/bad he is but a keeper I've watched for 2 yrs and nigh on 90 matches I'm not supposed to have an opinion on and say is a liability. He's the only thing that's not been changed in a defence that's conceded 10s of goals in 2years.

Mignolet played behind Van Dyke and was still garbage.

You ask for an aerial leader - Bartley was talking all the way through that game yesterday. The only time Johnson did really come out he punched Bartley mostly and the ball dropped in our box. Useless.

That’s not what I’m saying at all, I’m saying I’ve not seen Johnstone do anything to deserve being dropped yet. Which of the goals we’ve conceded this season should he have done better for? He is yet to cost us a goal... meanwhile, in his 2 appearances so far I’ve seen nothing from Button that makes me think we’ve got a budding Buffon waiting to usurp Johnstone from the bench.

I get that older football fans want to see goalie come and catch a ball when it comes into the box, but how many still do? Teams defend deeper at set pieces now, keepers are told to stay on their line, and players no longer mark the post. It’s all about cutting a delivery out before it makes it into the danger zone, instead of letting it into the danger zone hoping the keeper claims it.  Ever find yourself bemoaning corners not beating the first man anymore?! It’s how teams defend them (unless Phillips is taking them, because he is garbage).

I really do not know why people let Johnstone’s presence in our team annoy them so much. He’s probably 5th or 6th down the list of players that need replacing.

He's cost us one last night imho.

As for your analysis of how team's defend now I couldn't disagree more. Just look at how Guardiola and Klopp defend set pieces, they are high and pressing up with their goalkeepers barking at them to keep their line. As soon as any 6yd box becomes filled with players anything can happen when you've got a 5'5" keeper

Which one did he cost us yesterday? Absolutely none of those were his fault, only someone with an agenda would entertain that thought. 

Always good to use Guardiola and Klopp as an example of how all teams defend, with arguably the best CBs and GKs in the league! Also, almost half of the goals Man City concede come from set pieces....

If you think the way to defend freekicks coming into the box is to sit as deep as possible in my humble opinion you know fook all about defending and explains why you think Johnstone is a good keeper
Reply
(09-27-2020, 12:18 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:16 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:43 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:00 AM)billybassett Wrote: A man you've seen play just twice is now not good enough to be given a chance to show how good/bad he is but a keeper I've watched for 2 yrs and nigh on 90 matches I'm not supposed to have an opinion on and say is a liability. He's the only thing that's not been changed in a defence that's conceded 10s of goals in 2years.

Mignolet played behind Van Dyke and was still garbage.

You ask for an aerial leader - Bartley was talking all the way through that game yesterday. The only time Johnson did really come out he punched Bartley mostly and the ball dropped in our box. Useless.

That’s not what I’m saying at all, I’m saying I’ve not seen Johnstone do anything to deserve being dropped yet. Which of the goals we’ve conceded this season should he have done better for? He is yet to cost us a goal... meanwhile, in his 2 appearances so far I’ve seen nothing from Button that makes me think we’ve got a budding Buffon waiting to usurp Johnstone from the bench.

I get that older football fans want to see goalie come and catch a ball when it comes into the box, but how many still do? Teams defend deeper at set pieces now, keepers are told to stay on their line, and players no longer mark the post. It’s all about cutting a delivery out before it makes it into the danger zone, instead of letting it into the danger zone hoping the keeper claims it.  Ever find yourself bemoaning corners not beating the first man anymore?! It’s how teams defend them (unless Phillips is taking them, because he is garbage).

I really do not know why people let Johnstone’s presence in our team annoy them so much. He’s probably 5th or 6th down the list of players that need replacing.

He's cost us one last night imho.

As for your analysis of how team's defend now I couldn't disagree more. Just look at how Guardiola and Klopp defend set pieces, they are high and pressing up with their goalkeepers barking at them to keep their line. As soon as any 6yd box becomes filled with players anything can happen when you've got a 5'5" keeper

Which one did he cost us yesterday? Absolutely none of those were his fault, only someone with an agenda would entertain that thought. 

Always good to use Guardiola and Klopp as an example of how all teams defend, with arguably the best CBs and GKs in the league! Also, almost half of the goals Man City concede come from set pieces....

If you think the way to defend freekicks coming into the box is to sit as deep as possible in my humble opinion you know fook all about defending and explains why you think Johnstone is a good keeper
He in no way cost us a goal yesterday. Just because some of you dislike the bloke, not every goal conceded is down to him. I refer back to some of last seasons posts you show me how many points he lost us last season and now this season.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 12:29 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:18 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 12:16 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:43 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: That’s not what I’m saying at all, I’m saying I’ve not seen Johnstone do anything to deserve being dropped yet. Which of the goals we’ve conceded this season should he have done better for? He is yet to cost us a goal... meanwhile, in his 2 appearances so far I’ve seen nothing from Button that makes me think we’ve got a budding Buffon waiting to usurp Johnstone from the bench.

I get that older football fans want to see goalie come and catch a ball when it comes into the box, but how many still do? Teams defend deeper at set pieces now, keepers are told to stay on their line, and players no longer mark the post. It’s all about cutting a delivery out before it makes it into the danger zone, instead of letting it into the danger zone hoping the keeper claims it.  Ever find yourself bemoaning corners not beating the first man anymore?! It’s how teams defend them (unless Phillips is taking them, because he is garbage).

I really do not know why people let Johnstone’s presence in our team annoy them so much. He’s probably 5th or 6th down the list of players that need replacing.

He's cost us one last night imho.

As for your analysis of how team's defend now I couldn't disagree more. Just look at how Guardiola and Klopp defend set pieces, they are high and pressing up with their goalkeepers barking at them to keep their line. As soon as any 6yd box becomes filled with players anything can happen when you've got a 5'5" keeper

Which one did he cost us yesterday? Absolutely none of those were his fault, only someone with an agenda would entertain that thought. 

Always good to use Guardiola and Klopp as an example of how all teams defend, with arguably the best CBs and GKs in the league! Also, almost half of the goals Man City concede come from set pieces....

If you think the way to defend freekicks coming into the box is to sit as deep as possible in my humble opinion you know fook all about defending and explains why you think Johnstone is a good keeper
He in no way cost us a goal yesterday. Just because some of you dislike the bloke, not every goal conceded is down to him. I refer back to some of last seasons posts you show me how many points he lost us last season and now this season.

Off the top of my head definitely 2 at Charlton and 2 against Forest and Barnsely
Reply
The first goal is because his weight is on his wrong foot. He gambled on the shot going to his left and it didn’t. Had he not he’d have probably made a comfortable save. I’d put that down to goalkeeper error.

He didn’t make a single save or claim a cross that you wouldn’t expect any first choice keeper at 91 other clubs.

The 3rd? It’s not the first time he’s palmed back into play, in fact it’s only been a week since the last time he did it. Stuart Naylor did it all the time. Blame the defenders for not reacting? Sure, but forwards all round the world tend to react quicker in those situations. I wouldn’t put the entire fault of the goal on his shoulders though. Ffs sake Kanu!

Goalkeeper errors are always highlighted much more because invariably it leads to a goal and it’s the only influence they have on a game. A defender may head the ball away 20 times in a game and miss the 21st.

I’ve said it before when it’s reactionary he’s fine, as soon as he has to think or make a decision it goes to shit. He’s part of the reason we’re conceding, not the only reason. A better keeper would have less saves to make as they’d organise the defence better. And to an extent a better defender may make SJs job easier. Given we’re not changing Johnstone we’d better hope that Ivanovic is the answer.

For those that keep count I’d say his +/- on points is currently sitting on -2 for the season.

We’d have won the game without the first going in.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 12:43 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: The first goal is because his weight is on his wrong foot. He gambled on the shot going to his left and it didn’t.  Had he not he’d have probably made a comfortable save.  I’d put that down to goalkeeper error.

He didn’t make a single save or claim a cross that you wouldn’t expect any first choice keeper at 91 other clubs. 

The 3rd?  It’s not the first time he’s palmed back into play, in fact it’s only been a week since the last time he did it.  Stuart Naylor did it all the time.  Blame the defenders for not reacting? Sure, but forwards all round the world tend to react quicker in those situations.  I wouldn’t put the entire fault of the goal on his shoulders though.  Ffs sake Kanu!

Goalkeeper errors are always highlighted much more because invariably it leads to a goal and it’s the only influence they have on a game.  A defender may head the ball away 20 times in a game and miss the 21st. 

I’ve said it before when it’s reactionary he’s fine, as soon as he has to think or make a decision it goes to shit.  He’s part of the reason we’re conceding, not the only reason.  A better keeper would have less saves to make as they’d organise the defence better.  And to an extent a better defender may make SJs job easier.  Given we’re not changing Johnstone we’d better hope that Ivanovic is the answer.

For those that keep count I’d say his +/- on points is currently sitting on -2 for the season.

We’d have won the game without the first going in.

He was in the right place had Livermore closed down Mount, instead he skips past him and finds space to get a shot off before SJ can readjust... for me the blame for that goal lies with Furlong for failing to pick up Azpilicueta and then Livermore for not taking the man... 

I agree the third goal needed a stronger hand, but the ball should never have got to that point. Townsend should have been stronger, HRK should have cleared it, and O’Shea switched off letting Abraham get goal side, and then failed to react when SJ pushed the ball out.

Given goalkeepers are usually the final piece in any goal going in, it’s easy to attribute blame to them, but there are far more guilty parties in all 3 goals than Johnstone. He could have done a little better on the third, but chances are with Oshea being where he was, any stop would have fallen to Abraham.

Neither of those goals are mistakes to SJ, the fault lies far further down the move.
Reply
CA Baggie Wrote:The first goal is because his weight is on his wrong foot. He gambled on the shot going to his left and it didn’t.  Had he not he’d have probably made a comfortable save.  I’d put that down to goalkeeper error.

He didn’t make a single save or claim a cross that you wouldn’t expect any first choice keeper at 91 other clubs. 

The 3rd?  It’s not the first time he’s palmed back into play, in fact it’s only been a week since the last time he did it.  Stuart Naylor did it all the time.  Blame the defenders for not reacting? Sure, but forwards all round the world tend to react quicker in those situations.  I wouldn’t put the entire fault of the goal on his shoulders though.  Ffs sake Kanu!

Goalkeeper errors are always highlighted much more because invariably it leads to a goal and it’s the only influence they have on a game.  A defender may head the ball away 20 times in a game and miss the 21st. 

I’ve said it before when it’s reactionary he’s fine, as soon as he has to think or make a decision it goes to shit.  He’s part of the reason we’re conceding, not the only reason.  A better keeper would have less saves to make as they’d organise the defence better.  And to an extent a better defender may make SJs job easier.  Given we’re not changing Johnstone we’d better hope that Ivanovic is the answer.

For those that keep count I’d say his +/- on points is currently sitting on -2 for the season.

We’d have won the game without the first going in.
Some excellent points there. One other thing, though. A keeper that is more vocal and comes to claim the ball also wins the right to fall to the floor with it and take the sting out of the game. Sam barely ever has the ball in his hands and offers none of the dark art of timewasting that everyone at this level does so successfully. If he's the best we have then so be it but I don't fall for this "no one likes him 'cos he's ex villa) crap. He is an ex Man U player who we took from villa.  Personally, I'm not convinced he is improving enough but accept we may have more pressing concerns elsewhere in the team.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: