Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-11-2020, 11:37 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Remi does the maths on 'ere!
But I'll have a pop... 'Pools works out at £3,750 per seat, and whilst Aachen may have built a ground cheaper you can assume the Liverpool price is more along the lines of what it would cost over here. Official Halford's capacity is currently on 3,773 BTW. Can't really use the East STand to compare costs as it was built 19 years ago and things have gone up a lot since then.
In effect you're looking at a ten year season ticket to cover the build cost (ignoring maintenance) of each seat. That's also excluding the simple fact that the club would probably end up needing to pay a lot more to do something to Halford's Lane (sewers, gas mains, electric, broadband etc...) , they may even have to re-route part of the road, and that could then lead to changes needed at the Academy over the road, etc..., but would assume it would increase costs further. A simple 5,000 expansion would likely cost c£19m, based on Liverpool's costs, which may actually work out lower since they had more seats...add in that it's building on an existing structure & the road and you may well end up almost doubling the costs (based on it cost £16m for them to do Centenary Square in Brum (and that was largely a paving and putting in some nice garden bits and fountains type work...very little vertical stuff)).
I don't think we'd see much change from £30m, for something that may give us 5,000 more capacity which likely would rarely get past half full. *if* we get promoted *and* re-establish ourselves then I would say do it, until then it would be an expense that could impact promotion chances.
Good maths, but the re-establish ourselves thing is a misnomer. No one will ever re-establish themselves- outside the glory clubs every club walks the championship tightrope, where a club 8th is more likely to finish 18th next season than 6th. As i said earlier the right time to build is never.
We do also have the issue where the Halfords is a problem due to the proximity with the road. This is possibly one of the reasons we haven't expanded.
This is possibly the most insightful debate we've had on this.
(02-11-2020, 11:37 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Remi does the maths on 'ere!
But I'll have a pop... 'Pools works out at £3,750 per seat, and whilst Aachen may have built a ground cheaper you can assume the Liverpool price is more along the lines of what it would cost over here. Official Halford's capacity is currently on 3,773 BTW. Can't really use the East STand to compare costs as it was built 19 years ago and things have gone up a lot since then.
In effect you're looking at a ten year season ticket to cover the build cost (ignoring maintenance) of each seat. That's also excluding the simple fact that the club would probably end up needing to pay a lot more to do something to Halford's Lane (sewers, gas mains, electric, broadband etc...) , they may even have to re-route part of the road, and that could then lead to changes needed at the Academy over the road, etc..., but would assume it would increase costs further. A simple 5,000 expansion would likely cost c£19m, based on Liverpool's costs, which may actually work out lower since they had more seats...add in that it's building on an existing structure & the road and you may well end up almost doubling the costs (based on it cost £16m for them to do Centenary Square in Brum (and that was largely a paving and putting in some nice garden bits and fountains type work...very little vertical stuff)).
I don't think we'd see much change from £30m, for something that may give us 5,000 more capacity which likely would rarely get past half full. *if* we get promoted *and* re-establish ourselves then I would say do it, until then it would be an expense that could impact promotion chances.
Good points. I'm probably on the optimistic side and I think your synopsis is probably on the pessimistic side. Let's call it a round £23m for 5-6K extra seats.
But that still seems high per seat.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:00 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (02-11-2020, 08:52 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-10-2020, 08:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I don’t think some understand where we are financially so you might not get very sensible replies.
No one questions prudence at this point. But the 8 years on the trot when we were in the Prem....
Plus no one blinks an eye when we spend millions on dross - I say again Ideye, Burke, McMannaman, Lambert, Anichibe. There's probably close to £40m. I know the argument between players and stands is moot as you need players for success but we're not talking 100s of millions to redevelop the Halfords. I know someone who's company was asked 15 years ago (or maybe a bit more) to mock up some initial designs for the Halfords and draft costs. Different options were given as the road is an issue but they were feasible and - compared to the cost of those players - affordable.
You can spout as much sense as you wish but you'll find it very hard to persuade the icklealbioners of the merits of replacing a stand now in its fifth decade of use.
The point is it’s not us ‘icklealbioners’ that can make that happen.
Oh yes they can. Get off their backsides and get up the games to make us need a capacity increase
Check out our average attendance since Megson arrived 20 years ago, and we've operated at around 95% capacity every year until Pulis killed it for a lot of people. I'm expecting we'll find we're operating at 95% again this season. The only reason our average attendance hasn't increased during the Premier years is the club keep cutting capactiy. In this golden age of football it's utterly fuggin' perverse that we're doing this. Make hay while the sun shines. The Halfords is cramped and 40 years old now anyway - about time it got re-developed.
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
02-11-2020, 01:06 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-11-2020, 01:08 PM by Baggiejacko.)
(02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:00 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (02-11-2020, 08:52 AM)billybassett Wrote: No one questions prudence at this point. But the 8 years on the trot when we were in the Prem....
Plus no one blinks an eye when we spend millions on dross - I say again Ideye, Burke, McMannaman, Lambert, Anichibe. There's probably close to £40m. I know the argument between players and stands is moot as you need players for success but we're not talking 100s of millions to redevelop the Halfords. I know someone who's company was asked 15 years ago (or maybe a bit more) to mock up some initial designs for the Halfords and draft costs. Different options were given as the road is an issue but they were feasible and - compared to the cost of those players - affordable.
You can spout as much sense as you wish but you'll find it very hard to persuade the icklealbioners of the merits of replacing a stand now in its fifth decade of use.
The point is it’s not us ‘icklealbioners’ that can make that happen.
Oh yes they can. Get off their backsides and get up the games to make us need a capacity increase
Check out our average attendance since Megson arrived 20 years ago, and we've operated at around 95% capacity every year until Pulis killed it for a lot of people. I'm expecting we'll find we're operating at 95% again this season. The only reason our average attendance hasn't increased during the Premier years is the club keep cutting capactiy. In this golden age of football it's utterly fuggin' perverse that we're doing this. Make hay while the sun shines. The Halfords is cramped and 40 years old now anyway - about time it got re-developed.
Check out the average before and after Pulis and while he was here
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-11-2020, 01:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-11-2020, 01:57 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:00 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (02-11-2020, 08:52 AM)billybassett Wrote: No one questions prudence at this point. But the 8 years on the trot when we were in the Prem....
Plus no one blinks an eye when we spend millions on dross - I say again Ideye, Burke, McMannaman, Lambert, Anichibe. There's probably close to £40m. I know the argument between players and stands is moot as you need players for success but we're not talking 100s of millions to redevelop the Halfords. I know someone who's company was asked 15 years ago (or maybe a bit more) to mock up some initial designs for the Halfords and draft costs. Different options were given as the road is an issue but they were feasible and - compared to the cost of those players - affordable.
You can spout as much sense as you wish but you'll find it very hard to persuade the icklealbioners of the merits of replacing a stand now in its fifth decade of use.
The point is it’s not us ‘icklealbioners’ that can make that happen.
Oh yes they can. Get off their backsides and get up the games to make us need a capacity increase
Check out our average attendance since Megson arrived 20 years ago, and we've operated at around 95% capacity every year until Pulis killed it for a lot of people. I'm expecting we'll find we're operating at 95% again this season. The only reason our average attendance hasn't increased during the Premier years is the club keep cutting capactiy. In this golden age of football it's utterly fuggin' perverse that we're doing this. Make hay while the sun shines. The Halfords is cramped and 40 years old now anyway - about time it got re-developed.
I like the Halfords simply as it's handier for me geographically coming of the train. However, it is hugely uncomfortable for anyone even relatively tall. I struggle, being north of 6ft and just about the right height for an entry level Pulis player, to get comfortable, and for Jonas Ollson sized fans it's impossible.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(02-11-2020, 11:37 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:24 AM)billybassett Wrote: (02-11-2020, 10:02 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Fearing I repeat myself, Bill Dit and They Will Come. Unquestionably, for the big games. And, if allowed, incorporate a decent swathe of standing room. By not expanding we demonstrate our lack of ambition and our lack of belief that we can make our own future. Endz.
Exactly.
Liverpool's new main stand was for 20,000 sets. Cost £75m. Has 7500 hospitality seats - doubling what was there before - making in it's first year £12m.
Now we're no Liverpool. We don't want 20,000 seats. The current Halfords is 4700 people, the Smethick 5200. The new Rainbow cost just £8m for 8700 seats.
So we may be looking at increasing the Halfords and the corners to Smethwick and Brummie to make it 10000 across the piece. That probably gives a capacity of £31K plus loads of new corporate boxes.
Cost - what do you reckon - must be architects and developers on here - I reckon £25-30m. Call it 2.5 Brown Ideye's.
Look at Sunderland at the weekend - doing shit - but had a nice tasty game on paper - well priced - they got 33K. It aint rocket science Tom
Remi does the maths on 'ere!
But I'll have a pop... 'Pools works out at £3,750 per seat, and whilst Aachen may have built a ground cheaper you can assume the Liverpool price is more along the lines of what it would cost over here. Official Halford's capacity is currently on 3,773 BTW. Can't really use the East STand to compare costs as it was built 19 years ago and things have gone up a lot since then.
In effect you're looking at a ten year season ticket to cover the build cost (ignoring maintenance) of each seat. That's also excluding the simple fact that the club would probably end up needing to pay a lot more to do something to Halford's Lane (sewers, gas mains, electric, broadband etc...) , they may even have to re-route part of the road, and that could then lead to changes needed at the Academy over the road, etc..., but would assume it would increase costs further. A simple 5,000 expansion would likely cost c£19m, based on Liverpool's costs, which may actually work out lower since they had more seats...add in that it's building on an existing structure & the road and you may well end up almost doubling the costs (based on it cost £16m for them to do Centenary Square in Brum (and that was largely a paving and putting in some nice garden bits and fountains type work...very little vertical stuff)).
I don't think we'd see much change from £30m, for something that may give us 5,000 more capacity which likely would rarely get past half full. *if* we get promoted *and* re-establish ourselves then I would say do it, until then it would be an expense that could impact promotion chances.
£30M-ish
Borrow most of that over 7 to 10 years.
Wim goowin up, so Nike slogan please.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-11-2020, 01:06 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:00 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: You can spout as much sense as you wish but you'll find it very hard to persuade the icklealbioners of the merits of replacing a stand now in its fifth decade of use.
The point is it’s not us ‘icklealbioners’ that can make that happen.
Oh yes they can. Get off their backsides and get up the games to make us need a capacity increase
Check out our average attendance since Megson arrived 20 years ago, and we've operated at around 95% capacity every year until Pulis killed it for a lot of people. I'm expecting we'll find we're operating at 95% again this season. The only reason our average attendance hasn't increased during the Premier years is the club keep cutting capactiy. In this golden age of football it's utterly fuggin' perverse that we're doing this. Make hay while the sun shines. The Halfords is cramped and 40 years old now anyway - about time it got re-developed.
Check out the average before and after Pulis and while he was here
wiki figures:
2012–13 25,366
2013–14 25,196
2014–15 25,064
2015–16 24,631
2016–17 23,876
2017–18 24,520
2018–19 24,148
Pulis was manager 1/1/15 - 20/11/17 (2 full seasons in bold).
Posts: 986
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
Nobody is mentioning the corporate income. A new Halfords would increase corporate and non matchday income through office space, possible hotel and conferencing.
When Villa went down we were turning businesses away because we were maxed out.
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(02-11-2020, 01:29 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 01:06 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The point is it’s not us ‘icklealbioners’ that can make that happen.
Oh yes they can. Get off their backsides and get up the games to make us need a capacity increase
Check out our average attendance since Megson arrived 20 years ago, and we've operated at around 95% capacity every year until Pulis killed it for a lot of people. I'm expecting we'll find we're operating at 95% again this season. The only reason our average attendance hasn't increased during the Premier years is the club keep cutting capactiy. In this golden age of football it's utterly fuggin' perverse that we're doing this. Make hay while the sun shines. The Halfords is cramped and 40 years old now anyway - about time it got re-developed.
Check out the average before and after Pulis and while he was here
wiki figures:
2012–13 25,366
2013–14 25,196
2014–15 25,064
2015–16 24,631
2016–17 23,876
2017–18 24,520
2018–19 24,148
Pulis was manager 1/1/15 - 20/11/17 (2 full seasons in bold).
Hardly droves disappeared and returned during that period. This season is 24,182 so far. Top 3 all season and the most entertainment for years. Still well south of capacity
Posts: 1,456
Threads: 102
Joined: Jan 2019
(02-11-2020, 01:17 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 01:01 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-11-2020, 09:00 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: You can spout as much sense as you wish but you'll find it very hard to persuade the icklealbioners of the merits of replacing a stand now in its fifth decade of use.
The point is it’s not us ‘icklealbioners’ that can make that happen.
Oh yes they can. Get off their backsides and get up the games to make us need a capacity increase
Check out our average attendance since Megson arrived 20 years ago, and we've operated at around 95% capacity every year until Pulis killed it for a lot of people. I'm expecting we'll find we're operating at 95% again this season. The only reason our average attendance hasn't increased during the Premier years is the club keep cutting capactiy. In this golden age of football it's utterly fuggin' perverse that we're doing this. Make hay while the sun shines. The Halfords is cramped and 40 years old now anyway - about time it got re-developed.
I like the Halfords simply as it's handier for me geographically coming of the train.
On about extending it, not relocating it to Tat Bank Road
|