(07-29-2019, 04:35 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: It is. And of course people will argue against the points made which is fair enough but no one on either side of the debate can say what exact figures will happen in the future and what the exact trade scenarios will be - they are projections and suppositions by all. For me I have no doubt an economy the size of the UK can exist comfortably inside or outside the EU and how well it does that depends on competence of government and external factors too such as the global economy (in general and in the EU and ithers we do a lot of trade with) and oil prices and so on. So staying in or leaving for me has been more about the way rhe EU is going and its governance and whether it is the direction the UK should go in. I wasnt around to vote and id have been in two minds. Once the vote was to leave though it should have been honoured by MPs and not blocked by them as if they were above the vote like in a communist or fascist state rather than in a democracy. I think not leaving now would be morally wrong.
I'm going to break the habit of most of a lifetime here and be slightly charitable towards MPs; and I'm talking about the majority, as opposed to the fringe elements.
I don't believe that the delay has simply been a matter of "We know better and we're not having it". My view is that the first mistake was parliament not clarifying an agreed form of Brexit prior to triggering Article 50; other mistakes have flowed from that but MPs committing themselves to a 2-year straitjacket - having already established how easy it had been to fritter away the 9 months since the public vote - didn't take into account either the complexity of the matter at hand or the many different opinions of what was meant by Brexit. It's turned out to be a bit less simplistic than "Brexit means Brexit".
That way we might have saved ourselves the embarrassment of constructing a deal to which the only one of the 28 states who couldn't agree was ourselves; a deal which some are still suggesting the EU27 might be prepared - even at this late stage in the proceedings - to tweak or, even more optimistically redraft. Otherwise, it's crash-out, which would be tantamount to three and a half years spent negotiating nothing and living with the consequences.
If it had turned out that, even after an extended timescale, there was no form of withdrawal to which parliament could commit itself that would have been - to put it mildly - a difficult moment for our democracy. It might also, though, have demonstrated to our political classes the implications of making promises on which they have no idea how to deliver.
Just shy of 500 MPs voted to trigger Article 50, which suggests no conspiracy to obstruct at that stage; that's about as charitable as I can muster.

