"But as I wrote earlier the BBC cannot attempt to be all things to all men simply because it no longer has the financial clout."
If I was trying to 'fix' the BBC, I would say you've got it right there. But money is only half the problem. The Government doesn't know what it wants the BBC to be and changing with every new government wouldn't make sense. It's board of trustees don't know what it should be and neither does the BBC itself. Consequently, neither does the public. Worse still, they're trying to do everything and a lot of it not very well. Therefore, why would the public be happy paying?
They have still got the money but the question is more should they be trying to compete in all areas? is that really their job? Should they be trying to go head to head with ITV at primetime? If they decide they should, make it clear why, and decide what competing means. For me, it should be by doing something different. It shouldn't be putting a gameshow up against another gameshow. It certainly shouldn't be trying to outbid ITV for a household celebrity.
If I was being cynical and I was putting aside questions of quality and choice, it's self-defeating anyway. You can't earn export fees on British gameshows and expensive British led celebrity vehicles add costs that can't be recouped by selling to other markets where that celebrity isn't celebrated.
And the more we do this, the more that the BBC will be undermined by people saying this is shit and I can get this for less or free on ITV, Netflix, Disney, Paramount, Sky....
If I was trying to 'fix' the BBC, I would say you've got it right there. But money is only half the problem. The Government doesn't know what it wants the BBC to be and changing with every new government wouldn't make sense. It's board of trustees don't know what it should be and neither does the BBC itself. Consequently, neither does the public. Worse still, they're trying to do everything and a lot of it not very well. Therefore, why would the public be happy paying?
They have still got the money but the question is more should they be trying to compete in all areas? is that really their job? Should they be trying to go head to head with ITV at primetime? If they decide they should, make it clear why, and decide what competing means. For me, it should be by doing something different. It shouldn't be putting a gameshow up against another gameshow. It certainly shouldn't be trying to outbid ITV for a household celebrity.
If I was being cynical and I was putting aside questions of quality and choice, it's self-defeating anyway. You can't earn export fees on British gameshows and expensive British led celebrity vehicles add costs that can't be recouped by selling to other markets where that celebrity isn't celebrated.
And the more we do this, the more that the BBC will be undermined by people saying this is shit and I can get this for less or free on ITV, Netflix, Disney, Paramount, Sky....

