Left Wing politics at its most juvenile
#43
(10-06-2026, 11:33 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If the reservations for West Germany were not used, which they weren't, then they were not applicable. This is like saying Canada wasn't functionally independent after 1931. West Germany was not occupied after 1952 outside of the Saarland, civil control was based in the Bonn government and not London, Paris and DC.

The PA was not transitioned into power in Gaza, it wasn't even warned of the withdrawal. Being told one day without warning that Israel was retreating from Gaza tomorrow, here's the keys, good luck is not a transition. There is no capacity to build up institutions and establish civil control there, that is why there was a power vacuum.

Someone's clutching at straws here but it's not me. You can't hide behind legal frameworks to distract from what actually happened.

So no response to your false equivalence and fantasy then, after accusing me of the same? Thought not, just more obfuscation.

Where to start?

Saying reserved Allied rights "were never used" is factually wrong, the latest in a long line of mistruths you've presented as facts during our debate, there are more to come too. The Allies used their reserved powers continuously up until the 1968 Emergency Acts, even after this they retained supreme legal authority over West Berlin until 1990, and maintained military jurisdiction over all foreign troop deployments in West Germany (doesn't sound like any sovereign country I know). Your Strawman comparing a defeated, four-power occupied state to Canada voluntarily transitioning out of the British Empire via the 1931 Statute of Westminster is another absurd false equivalence.

To your second point, claiming the PA was given "no warning" on Gaza is a complete rewrite of reality ffs.

The Knesset passed the Disengagement Law in February 2005. The actual withdrawal didn't happen until August 2005. The PA had six months of explicit advanced notice of the withdrawal, moreover, Sharon first announced their intention to withdraw in December 2003, that's 20 months lead-in time for the PA to prepare; there were international coordination and cooperation efforts led by James Wolfensohn on getting agricultural infrastructure directly into PA control, this was clearly not a case of here are the keys good luck, as you seem to want to paint it.

More importantly, Hamas didn't seize Gaza "tomorrow" in 2005, they ousted the PA in June 2007, two full years later. The PA had the best part of 2 years, tens of thousands of security personnel, and international financial backing to govern Gaza. Again, they didn't lose Gaza because of a "lack of warning" they lost it because Hamas routed them in less than a week in a civil war.

If two years, international funding, and thousands of armed guards weren't enough time for the PA to maintain control against well-armed and motivated extremists, a 'negotiated transition' on a piece of paper won't save them in the West Bank either. You'll hit bedrock soon.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: Left Wing politics at its most juvenile - by Jacko - 10-06-2026, 12:15 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: