08-15-2026, 11:32 AM
(08-15-2026, 11:24 AM)Squid Wrote: Arday's appointment to the role was national news. Cambridge publicised it for all it was worth. All the cries about "What about other academics??", other academics don't have their memoirs published by a leading publishing house.
The people on here and elsewhere blaming this entirely on media coverage are missing the point. Arday had built (and indeed been actively helped to build) a massive house of cards. There is no way that it wasn't going to collapse and collapse very messily. Plagiarism and research fraud are one thing, Walter Mitty tales are another, but very rarely do you get both and at such a high profile institution. In addition to all that, Arday/Cambridge had tried to squash the story using the combined might of Carter-Ruck and the police, seemingly without any thought of the impact that might have to those on the receiving end.
Other academics tried to raise concerns about his work via academic means. Arday publicly accused them of racist harassment:
https://retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/c...exclusive/
For those wanting to point the finger entirely at the media. What do you think should have happened instead? As on the balance of things, a pattern of such consistent plagiarism and research fraud plus the fantastical claims about his life means that he would have at the very least been asked to step down and would have had his memoir cancelled.
Fair post.
I think though that for me the social media aspect is probably more to blame with people taking up arms immediately for and against someone with whom they had no connection and made it their fuggin raison d'etre for that 10 seconds or so. The media then tend to jump on top of stories like this because of the wider impact they have which exacerbates the situation.

