07-26-2026, 06:29 PM
(07-26-2026, 05:39 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote:(07-26-2026, 01:49 PM)Squid Wrote:(07-26-2026, 01:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(07-26-2026, 01:12 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I personally don't openly support LGBTQ+, if anything I feel the group is pushed too much onto society, but that doesn't mean I think people should be judged for their sexuality. In fact, I'm all for people being with whoever they want, as long as they're happy. Ditto gender alliance. I'm a little ignorant, and I don't understand how someone can identify as non-binary, for example, but if that's their wish, they're happy, and they're not hurting anyone, you crack on! It's all about being respectful of other people and how they live their life. I feel I don't need to support a group in order to hold those principles.
You don't need to join a movement or wave flags to believe in equality. You don't have to march through Birmingham in a rainbow and sequin encrusted crop top either.
You don't have to answer, but if your employer asked you to wear a pin for one day saying you supported equal pay for women in the office, the idea that black people have equal rights to white people, or that a man should be allowed to love another man without fear of losing his job, being arrested or being put to death, or a little closer to home, the Men's Minds Matter pin around male suicide prevention, would you? Or would you decline to do so because you don't want to openly support these causes?
You can be passively neutral to a cause, but when you're presented with a simple opportunity to publicly affirm a principle such as this, and you decline it, then I am entitled to conclude from that behaviour that your commitment to equality has limits.
The idea that wearing badges is anything other than a tick box exercise that generates anything other landfill waste is laughable. It is the height of corporate nonsense that makes bosses look like they are doing something when actually nothing is changing.
So, yes I would object quite a lot if my boss asked me to act as a walking corporate branding exercise without actually doing anything themselves.
Anyway, I'm taking no lectures from someone who sees fit to dismiss someone's entire career over a pair of shoelaces.
Exactly.
SW4 is everything that I despair about as I coax intolerant right leaning friends into a discussion where I can influence them into more tolerance for a different way of thinking that’s kinder to the world.
Many people are conservative and have engrained views that can only change with gentle persuasion.
Rainbow laces, rainbow footballs, rainbow shoes, jackets, flags etc creates as much aversion as it does positive energy.
SW4 is the epitome of identity politics at its most toxic. He’s manna from heaven for the Daily Mail.
Sorry, but I’m going to push back when I’m misrepresented. I can’t sit here and have views attributed to me that I never expressed.
Squid… you claimed I’d “dismissed his entire career over a pair of shoelaces.” That’s simply false. I explicitly described Hegazi as a great player and a brilliant signing before saying I’d lost some respect for him over this one decision. I don’t mind if you disagree with my opinion, but I do mind when you invent a more extreme version of it so you can indulge in a bit of faux outrage.
Bertie… you’ve now turned that into me being “the epitome of identity politics at its most toxic.” Again, that’s based on an argument I never made. I never said everyone has to wave rainbow flags, become an activist or agree with every LGBT campaign. I said that making a conscious decision to reject a gesture promoting equality is a decision I find disappointing, and one I’m perfectly entitled to judge.
If your only way of rebutting my point is to invent a more extreme position for me so you can argue against it, that’s actually peak culture-war politics. Ironically, it’s exactly the kind of tribal stereotyping you claim to dislike. Maybe you’re spending too much time with your right leaning friends!
If you want to engage with what I actually said, I’m happy to debate it. If you’d rather keep arguing with a caricature of my position while congratulating yourselves on defending a version of liberalism that nobody here was challenging, be my guest.


