07-22-2026, 09:20 AM
(07-22-2026, 08:18 AM)Logic1 Wrote:(07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.
I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.
The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.
I don't think anyone is claiming anything about magical powers. Just basic competence in managing budgets, assessing likely behavioural impacts or the opportunity cost of policymaking. I don't believe any member of the government has applied an innovation in their working lives that has saved money or improved productivity.
I find that final contention quite bewildering too, though that said we have just suffered "an economist" as Chancellor so maybe you're right. We're about to find out.

