06-28-2026, 03:19 PM
(06-28-2026, 02:54 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(06-28-2026, 02:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(06-27-2026, 11:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Tbf, Lewis Hall should have gone too over Spence for me.
Agree.
I understand selecting one of James and Livramiento, but both, given their injury record was crazy, and then replacing the latter with Chalobah is the kind of decision that wlll cost us competitiveness.
TAA isn’t the answer, even more so after how poor he’s been in Madrid this year, where he’s mostly played when Carvajal’s legs needed a rest.
Hall should absolutely have gone, and I’d have called up Shaw. Don’t think he’s ever formally retired from England duty, and he’s just had his strongest season for United in probably 6 years. Rico Lewis also seems criminally underused by England.
The fact we have Djed Spence and Jarrel Quansah playing as fullback options in this WC is entirely down to Tuchel, not lack of better options.
I just hope we make serious progress as those selections fully warrant any ire the coaching team receive.
I was surprised by some of the selections made by Tuchel...wouldn't go as far as to say that they will cost us the chance to win the tournament.
Far too many central defenders, when we are short of one or two central midfielders.
Personally i would have taken Palmer, Wharton, Lewis-Skelly and maybe Hall (not sure he's a big enough upgrade on Spence), instead of Chalobah, Burn and Henderson .
But if we do well in the tournament, it will be because our top players (Kane, Bellingham, Rice, Saka and Rashford) have performed when it absolutely matters, not because of who was chosen as the fourth choice central midfielder.
I didn’t say we’d lose the tournament because of it, I agree with you Shabby, but in our three games so far the fullback areas have been huge contributors to poor performances. Both Ghana and Panama shut us down due to our lack of width, and the first half against Croatia followed a similar pattern of us being so predictable due to no support out wide… especially with so many wide players lacking form.
Not sure Wharton would have added anything Rice and Anderson don’t already bring, but our lack of creativity through the centre has been clear.
Hopefully we can find a way through DRC who will absolutely repeat the Ghana playbook, and then it maybe TT’s selection will start to pay off.

