(05-21-2026, 08:29 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the EFL process is over, the FA could get involved and ban anyone involved for 12 months.
And this is where I'd draw the line.
Eckhert has actually been surprisingly open about this, accepted responsibility and said he did it having done it on the continent and being unaware of the rules here. I do believe that whilst cheating needs to be punished, his motivation was done through mistakenly believing it was allowed. He's a young coach, in his first managerial job and working under pressure. He will lose his job this week, and his reputation is in tatters in the UK, I don't see the need to punish him with a ban. He will be untouchable for 12 months at least in the British game anyway.
I think they hand him a fine, and let him get on with his career. His next job will be back in France or Germany regardless of whether the FA ban him in England or not.
(05-21-2026, 08:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: @SW4 - The EFL didn't decide the punishment, it was an independent panel, wasn't it? Did the EFL push for the expulsion verdict, or have they remained neutral?
My comment about changing rules retrospectively was a tongue in cheek joke aimed at their shenanigans with our PSR breach, it wasn't meant as a serious suggestion!
I still believe the punishment is disproportionate, but I'm not sure what other punishment would suffice. A fine, regardless of amount, doesn't seem to be enough, a points deduction for next season wouldn't be relevant to this, so I can understand the logic of expelling them from the play-offs, I genuinely understand that, I don't agree with it, as it doesn't feel right to me, but then again, as I've just said, any other punishment wouldn't feel right in terms of not being enough.
It's a messy situation, and I could honestly understand why any team involved would seek legal action, from Saints, to Boro and Hull, I could see logic in the arguments each team would bring.
All this confusion, uncertainty, the creation of a shit show, before you go into fans buying tickets/booking hotels etc etc, for negligible advantage gain. I just can't understand why Southampton have risked so much. It's brain-dead on their part.
I think the EFL's disciplinary action is always undertaken by an independent panel where there isn't an agreed punishment already in their guidelines, hence this one going to an independent panel.
I think with us, the EFL prepared the evidence for our breach and suggested the punishment based on their table, and an independent body still deliberated and decided - or I may well be totally wrong


