05-21-2026, 08:17 AM
(05-21-2026, 06:41 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:(05-21-2026, 06:23 AM)Jacko Wrote:(05-20-2026, 06:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm aware the rules were changed after Leeds, and it's a slightly different scenario in that it was a league game as opposed to a play-off game, but it's some difference to fine Leeds £200k when they were found guilty, and then expel Saints from the final, robbing them a chance to win £200mil. It's a massive difference for similar breaches, isn't it? No matter how you dress it up.
I still feel this is a disproportionate punishment. Yes, I know I'm in the minority in this. And yes, they should face punishment, and yes, they're very much in the wrong, and, yes, they have only themselves to blame for being so dishonourable (I'll state that again!). That's not me trying to be argumentative or contrary, that's my honest feeling. It doesn't feel the right to me.
The whole situation is a mess. I can't see any scenario that doesn't end up messy, and a club(s) initiating some form of legal proceedings. Farcical, from many points of view.
You need to forget about Leeds, there was no spying law in place at that time, this case is the precedent not Leeds/Derby. Then you will understand the sanction.
The EFL could have retrospectively changed the rules to punish Leeds more severely, if they wanted to.
I'm sure they've got previous in changing rules retrospectively...
The difference is that Leeds did it in a mid season fixture in January... Saints have done it during the playoffs.
Had this charge only related to the Oxford or Ipswich games, I'm sure a 1 or 2 point deduction, declaring the game null and void and awarding the standard 3-0 win to the opposition, or a 200k fine could be plausible, but in this case, kicking them out of the playoffs was the only option.
A points deduction next season doesn't offset the disadvantage Boro received, and retrospectively deducting them 3-4 points now wouldn't have altered the finishing positons. Awarding a 3-0 win instead of the 0-0 would have the same result in that Boro would go through, and Saints would likely argue the second leg would then need to be replayed causing more upheaval, and even a fine of several million pounds would be seen as a decent risk against the possible riches promotion would bring. We also know that had Saints won promotion, the EPL would be unlikely to hand them a large points deduction or restrict their spending power as they do not want to dilute their product - a promoted team startng on -4 points or more pretty much fills a relegation spot from day one.
The EFL have got this absolutely bang on. As I said on a previous threat, Saints wanted to disadvantage Boro in their chance to win promotion, any punishment has to be proportional to this.

