Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final
#85
(05-19-2026, 08:12 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: This thread has descended into as much of a farce as the EFL's ability to make rules and adhere them.

It's pretty simple. They've cheated by breaking a defined rule around spying. The benefit they got from their actions is completely irrelevant.

The only reason there's so much discussion about the punishment is because the EFL are fucking awful at governance and haven't put in the specific sanction for this type of cheating, leading to calls for everything from a slap on the wrists to the expulsion of them from football.

I can sort of see where KRO is coming from, but players resorting to the "dark arts" of diving etc isn't really comparable to organised spying at the club level. They're both cheating but it's like comparing a crackhead shoplifting steaks to sell for his next fix and organised criminals doing a smash and grab on a jewellery store. The punishment should therefore fit the crime. The crackhead gets at worst a slap on the wrists (in the football sense, probably a yellow card), the organised criminal if caught gets jail time (in this case, expulsion from the playoffs).

Agree completely - the outcome of the cheating does not impact the punishment - it is the action itself that has to be punished.

If you cheated on your missus with another woman but didn't enjoy the sex, I'm sure she wouldn't forgive you due to the lack of your desired outcome, in the same way if you cheated on a test at school and still failed, you'd still be punished for cheating, as well as being widely and deservedly mocked for cheating so badly.

The way in which Saints cheated was ridiculous... the photo is hilarious, and they need to be both widely mocked and reviled for doing so. By the sounds of things the session they spied on was penalty practice, which had the game gone to pens, would have given them a huge advantage. Whether they needed it or not, they still cheated. It's like taking the results into a test on the back of your ruler, only for those questions not to come up, or arranging to meet another women, sending a few nudes and then when you show up her saying she's not up for it - you still deserve the punishment as you had the full intention of going through with it.

If they're not kicked out the final it's a disgrace IMO.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - by SW4Baggie - 05-19-2026, 10:41 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)