Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final
#36
(05-16-2026, 10:25 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(05-16-2026, 10:03 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Ok, what if the spying was as suspected is over the whole league and they’ve had the advantage over the whole season to get to the position they’re in now. Dress it up how you like Josh, a fine doesn’t remotely cut it given the riches on offer for the playoff winners.

Correct. If fees a little like arguing against it just to be oppositional. With the rewards at stake, cheating can and should have only one outcome

I'm genuinely not being oppositional on purpose. I've perhaps struggled to articulate my thoughts. Let's be clear, what Southampton has done is cheating, ridiculous, and should be punished. We can all agree on that much. I think where I'm struggling is the idea that this spying should result in the club losing their place in the PO final, I genuinely feel that's an OTT punishment. I know I'm in the minority with that opinion, if not alone, but it's not one I hold with the intention of deliberately being argumentative or different! 

Part of the issue in my mind is how much they've truly gained? Not that it's an excuse to use to defend them, and I'm far from defending them - I just feel, whilst cheating, there's far too much weight being added to the advantage they may have gained. People are discussing spying as if it's the sole reason they reached the play-offs and beat Boro. I genuinely disagree with the weight being given to spying for their results. 

Saints would have beaten Boro with or without spying, in fact, Boro were by far the better team in the first leg, which tells you that whatever information or data they gained from their cheating didn't work, there was no advantage in that regard. There's so much media, footage, and other data aroundt hat there is zero need to spy. I'm at a loss as to why they felt the need to? There's more than enough information on any professional team to be able to coach your team to carty out an effective gameplay to win a tie, or individual game of football.

Maybe the issue is with me. Maybe I'm being naive and underestimating what information Saints gathered v Boro. But, whilst, again, I want to see them punished, and it's right that they should be, there's a lot worse going on in football that boils my piss more, mostly the financial regulations and how often teams can get away with spunking money and not getting adequate punishments. 

I'm not here to ruffle feather,s or be a dick, those are my genuine thoughts. I appreciate the counter arguments, and I appreciate I'm alone in this. In fact, the counter arguments are reasonable. I obviously don't agree, but they're reasonable, and I understand the counter argument.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - by Josh1873 - 05-16-2026, 04:09 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)