(05-05-2026, 07:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:(05-05-2026, 07:07 AM)MrBater Wrote:(05-04-2026, 10:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: We haven't produced 'that group' again yet.
We spent that long neglecting the academy. We had 5/6 years of nothing.
The u18s are the next lot really. But they are 3/4 years away most likely.
How old were Rooney, Owen or Bellingham when they started playing for their clubs?? It's this mindset that holds us back I think. I have no idea about any of our U20s U 18s or whatever. It's also how Sunderland overcame the money problem to get promoted. if you don't play them you'll never know, and of course there's always a chance that our Academy actually, just isn't all that.
Agree, if you're good enough, you are old enough. That's where the coaches come in to assist with confidence, physical strengths etc. when the guys take a step up. But disagree on our Academy, it's widely respected. So much so that villa came in for half the kids and ALL of the coaches. The league is littered with our Academy products. It seems just Albion are reluctant to use them.
Yes, so a couple of years ago we were producing some quality, BUT nowadays who is there? Nobody seems to be poaching them anymore, are they not good enough or have we taken steps to stop the poaching?
(05-05-2026, 11:44 AM)MrBater Wrote:(05-05-2026, 07:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:(05-05-2026, 07:07 AM)MrBater Wrote:(05-04-2026, 10:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: We haven't produced 'that group' again yet.
We spent that long neglecting the academy. We had 5/6 years of nothing.
The u18s are the next lot really. But they are 3/4 years away most likely.
How old were Rooney, Owen or Bellingham when they started playing for their clubs?? It's this mindset that holds us back I think. I have no idea about any of our U20s U 18s or whatever. It's also how Sunderland overcame the money problem to get promoted. if you don't play them you'll never know, and of course there's always a chance that our Academy actually, just isn't all that.
Agree, if you're good enough, you are old enough. That's where the coaches come in to assist with confidence, physical strengths etc. when the guys take a step up. But disagree on our Academy, it's widely respected. So much so that villa came in for half the kids and ALL of the coaches. The league is littered with our Academy products. It seems just Albion are reluctant to use them.
Yes, so a couple of years ago we were producing some quality, BUT nowadays who is there? Nobody seems to be poaching them anymore, are they not good enough or have we taken steps to stop the poaching?
I firmly believe that without parachutes we simply have to trust the kids more and get them up to speed and then sell them on to keep us going. Unless we get some ridiculous fee for a player we've bought and I can't think who we have now that would command that.
All the names mentioned so far have been a few years ago, with none really filling the Academy regular void since.

