(04-13-2026, 03:15 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I worship at the altar of the NHS
But it can and must do better. And we should be looking at other countries.
https://www.internationalinsurance.com/h...I442X44bI3
Precisely. The Commonwealth Study consistently cites the UK as being incredibly efficient at producing poor outcomes. My family has received the dubious benefit of such outcomes in several occasions, which is the ONLY reason I now supplement NHS care with an exceptionally good value family policy through the company.
(04-13-2026, 03:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(04-13-2026, 03:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-13-2026, 02:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's ideological.
Yes, it is. Just like the NHS is now an unaffordable ideological anachronism (and the State Pension for that matter).
I would like to recreate the relationship between the individual and the state, that's all. In that respect I doubt I'm that far removed from Beveridge.
That's the point, you bang on about funding models when all the evidence says we need to fix primary and social care and that changing the funding model makes zero difference because we have universal healthcare obligations already. Unless you want us to go for what the Swiss have with the removal of universal healthcare.
It's not just the funding model. It's the whole relationship between the individual and the state:
Beveridge stated that social security must be a joint effort. The state offers security, but it is earned through service and contribution. While Beveridge proposed a primarily contribution-based system, the post-war welfare state evolved to be funded significantly by taxpayers, moving away from his original vision.
Beveridge said The state's role is to provide a comprehensive system of social insurance (combining the "five giants" of Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, and Idleness) that guarantees a subsistence-level income. Contrast that with the Triple Lock.
The system was based on contributions rather than charity, often referred to as "stamping the card," which was meant to encourage a feeling of partnership and entitlement. There is now just entitlement.
Beveridge emphasized that in establishing a national minimum, the state should not stifle "incentive, opportunity, [or] responsibility". The state was intended to leave "room and encouragement for voluntary action by each individual to provide more than that minimum for himself and his family". The system was not meant to create dependence but to provide a safety net for people to "build freely upon".
While establishing a comprehensive system, the state should not create a totalising, restrictive monopoly, but rather foster a "mixed economy" of welfare that includes voluntary action.
I'm with Beveridge.


