07-02-2019, 09:30 PM
(07-02-2019, 09:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:That's about right, fella. Overall I've quite enjoyed it, particularly the lack of acting and diving.(07-02-2019, 09:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: VAR is going to kill the game.
That or the offside rule is going to have to have some serious revision. VAR is providing the ability for referees to disallow goals for which the offside rules were never intended to be applied. When it comes down to small bit of players anatomy being deemed to be offside you know there is something wrong with the way in which VAR is being applied.
And what happen to the concept that VAR was only to be used for clear and obvious mistakes, that idea has suffered the early death that was always inevitable.
Wait till they extend, as they will, the types of incidents that can be subject to VAR - games will regularly last longer than 100 minutes, don't expect a Saturday 3 o'clock kick off game to finish anytime before 5 o'clock in future.
There is increasingly much to recommend the Championship.
I couldn’t disagree more.
VAR has been introduced because as the rewards and speed at which the game moves increases relying on humans to officiate when there are more accurate systems is silly
The offside rule states any part of the body by which the ball can be legitimately played, which was exactly why she was offside. The rule is an absolute, you either are or aren’t. Andy Gray and other Pundits may want to believe it’s all about daylight or advantages but it’s not. If any part of your body that can play the ball is even a fraction of a millimetre ahead, you’re offside. As soon as you deviate from this you open a whole can of worms that’s impossible to police. Much like with the ball crossing the line.
Both the decisions that involved VAR tonight got the correct result, and in a game as big as this that’s all you can ask. I appreciate the amount of time some decisions take needs work, but I’d sooner they used it than not.
People saying football is being ruined by it are just overreacting to something new. I wish we’d had it in the playoff semis... we’d be looking at PL football now and the Vile would be going into a long long wilderness..
(07-02-2019, 09:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Totally agree VAR is more trouble than it's worth. What I have noticed about this here Womens World Cup is this;
Passes are the difference (to the male game), the power/pace of the ball is so much slower.
Goalkeeping also looks weak
They don't act up, dive, roll around as much. Grealish would be useless in the Ladies game.
The refs allow you to push someone over when they are wasting time at the corner flag. (I'm all for that).
Jonathon Pearce is annoying at whatever he does.
Any way..What is it with England and semi finals?
Without wanting to be flippant about the women’s game, the goals and the pitches need to be smaller. There is nothing technical and tactical a female player cannot do as well as a male one given the same resources and coaching, however they will never be as strong, fast or as physically big as male players.
Compared to some of the top male goalies the average female keeper is a foot smaller, but defending the same area. No amount of coaching will overcome that.

