06-25-2019, 08:32 PM
(06-25-2019, 04:50 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:(06-25-2019, 08:38 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Selection matters JOK. Had you chosen, say, Germany, Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Belgium, or the Netherlands, your comparison would have looked less favourable. Instead you chose countries whose cultures (in terms of gender and religion) and systems (in terms of the role of the individual) are arguably further away from that of the UK.
I think you are missing the point somewhat. I was pointing out that the groups listed by Dek would not “look back fondly” anywhere pre 1973. Despite his denial I still read Dekka’s line as an endorsement of the E.U.s lead on enlightened legislation and pointed out that Britain was a more enlightened place than most, relatively speaking. Just because we may no longer be in the Union, and that’s still a big doubt, doesn’t mean those groups will see a reversal of the progress made in their rights. Why would it? Do you believe in the lie that half the population in the U.K. is racist, homophobic, misogynistic, narrow minded bigots. And those across the channel or should I say, Le Manche, are all all welcoming humanists?
Two points about the selections. As the line referred to a previous era, do you really want to mention Germany favourably against the U.K.? It’s record on all those groups was not, shall we say, spotless. As for the modern examples surely this makes the lie that the E.U. is a Utopia for minorities.
It is not a question of looking back fondly to “yesteryear “ but could pro Brexit supporters but looking forward with more confidence in our abilities.
My point was you suggested many older people voted to leave because they remember I assume better times before the E.U. I said I doubt the groups I mentioned would prefer to go back to 1973. The point about us being more progressive in the way we treat people than others predating the EU illustrates that the EU hasn’t hindered or meddled to the detriment progress on this. Do I think a post Brexit Independant UK under a Boris Johnson with the likes of Mogg, Jenkins pulling the strings in the background would further the rights and support those groups received without EU law? Of course I don’t they couldn’t careless about those groups unless it makes them look good fleetingly.
On the broader point of Brexit and the stereotypes that accompany leavers, let’s not pretend those accusations aren’t without merit.
Hate crime went up against against foreign nationals as soon as the result was announced. Coincidence? Lefty conspiracy? Or the fact the decision gave licence to many racist bigots the opportunity to think they can say and do exactly what they want?
Statistics showed that the older generations voted for Brexit
Less educated voted to leave according to research done at the time
I’m summary not all of those who voted Brexit were xenophobic, or less educated but a sizeable proportion were and that is the humongous elephant in the room no one on the Brexit side of the argument wants to admit.
I know that it’s now the done thing to frame the argument for Brexit as about sovereignty and democracy but it was driven by an anti-immigration rhetoric for years before the referendum was called. It’s a lie to pretend otherwise.

