The world has finally gone to hell in a handcart
#46
(06-25-2019, 04:50 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(06-25-2019, 08:38 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Selection matters JOK. Had you chosen, say, Germany, Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Belgium, or the Netherlands, your comparison would have looked less favourable.  Instead you chose countries whose cultures (in terms of gender and religion) and systems (in terms of the role of the individual) are arguably further away from that of the UK.

I think you are missing the point somewhat. I was pointing out that the groups listed by Dek would not “look back fondly” anywhere pre 1973. Despite his denial I still read Dekka’s  line as an endorsement of the E.U.s lead on enlightened legislation and pointed out that Britain was a more enlightened place than most, relatively speaking. Just because we may no longer be in the Union, and that’s still a big doubt, doesn’t mean those groups will see a reversal of the progress made in their rights. Why would it? Do you believe in the lie that half the population in the U.K. is racist, homophobic, misogynistic, narrow minded bigots. And those across the channel or should I say, Le Manche, are all all welcoming humanists?
Two points about the selections. As the line referred to a previous era, do you really want to mention Germany favourably against the U.K.? It’s record on all those groups was not, shall we say, spotless. As for the modern examples surely this makes the lie that the E.U. is a Utopia for minorities. 
It is not a question of looking back fondly to “yesteryear “ but could pro Brexit supporters but looking forward with more confidence in our abilities.

Both excellent posts in a perfectly rational difference of opinions - (as is DHs' post). Most articles online, or in the papers, appear to come from the pre determined opinion of the author. Likewise most debate on Brexit.   Just as, historically, getting out of the EU was the policy of the left, Tony Benn, Dennis Skinner, and Corbyn- would you believe?  Now it is the expanding outer fringes of both parties, although I'm guessing many toe the party line to keep their positions intact. The fact is, this is the first time many politicians have had to actually do something and the real problem is the absolute paucity in the quality and integrity of them. Cameron wasn't an idiot for calling the referendum, he was displaying his own self interest in retaining power. That it backfired is just a further example of how out of touch he was. (Along with most politicians, I will add).
Realistically, it is hard to argue that the UK has ever harvested the true benefits of membership that the rest of the EU has. I go to European cities, and not just their capitals, and am always impressed by public transport. Other countries have lowered pension age and improved workers rights.  Britain, for it's own reasons, have done none of this. Arguably, they have made things worse. We focused on London, on finance, on an endless supply of cheaper labour for our services, and on cheaper imported goods. Our society is stretched every which way, divided,  with a huge disparity of incomes, living standards, health.
Then, with all this mess we belatedly have to factor in environmental concerns. Long, long overdue.
The point I am labouring over is we have dishonest politicians and a disenfranchised public. We have Remainers sorting out Brexit and Leavers heckling destructively from the sidelines. I'm struggling to see any positive way through without damaging democracy.  Actually, IMO, whatever problems are created short term by Brexit, will eventually be overcome as trade and business leaders drive industry, and not our ineffective politicians. Austerity or Spend, Spend, Spend, neither have been any lasting solution. What we need from this is politicians that encourage long term plans, forward thinking, not short term-ism. An end to hailing charlatons from venture capitalism as "investors". An end to serial bankrupts being feted as entrepreneurs. The public weren't fooled, they were just too lazy to care. We are now reaching a stage when far more people are beginning to care. Which way it goes is hard to predict, but with environmentalists coming into the equation, we may at last see an end to the two party comfort zone that has sleepwalked us all into trouble.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: The world has finally gone to hell in a handcart - by Tom Joad - 06-25-2019, 06:59 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)