The world has finally gone to hell in a handcart
#44
(06-25-2019, 08:01 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 01:10 PM)ODerek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 12:46 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: Well, we can agree on the state of British politics, and the world’s for that matter, and the awful collection of politicians we find ourselves blessed with at present. I have no idea who I would vote for come the next G.E.
I would argue that older generations haven’t been selfish. Can you really believe that parents and grandparents would jeopardise their descendants future purely for their here and now? I believe that most of the mature voters chose as they did because they believed it was the correct coarse to take. It might be worth remembering that they have experience of living in both scenarios to base their views on.
Being more conciliatory and polite may not change the opinions of those in the opposite camp but calling people the ‘C’ word and lording a supposed superior intellect (sorry Dek but that is how it can come across at times) is certainly not going to persuade them to come out of their entrenched positions.
As I intimidated at the start, I understand and genuinely sympathise with your feeling of disenfranchisement but I do feel a little uneasy with the comment “Don’t wish... to accept”.  What is the alternative if not to go with the majority, however slim? Insurrection?
The c word was used because I see austerity measures hurting the most vulnerable in society the most. Cuts were inevitable and necessary to a certain degree but the extent and who and how they were targeted (genuinely disabled for example) when the government can find £1bn to prop itself up via the DUP is c-sh behaviour, and those voted for them are complicit in that so I stand by that remark. It won’t change their minds but nothing would, it is an ideological decision and if it’s not, then you have to question the intelligence of those who made the decisions because it’s going to cost us all more in the long term. The mantra at the time was we are all in this together, on reflection who have suffered the most from the cuts?

Regarding the remark not to accept the decision well those who have lobbied for 40yrs to leave never did and wouldn’t have regardless of the result, so if this decision turns out to be a disaster then I will vote for a party that would be pro rejoining.  I could be wrong and it’s all going to be great. I’m sure people will tell the remainers they were wrong in which case I will stfu. However if it becomes clear the majority were wrong what redress do remainers have? All I can see is a future where many of those who voted to leave will be the same people who have been hit hardest by Brexit in which case they will rightly be called masochists for prolonging at a guess austerity for another decade at least!  

Remembering yesteryear is a dangerous way to make decisions as memories are not fact and are tinged with nostalgia. Women’s rights, ethnic minorities, the disabled, gay people etc might not look back so fondly on pre EU Britain.

I don’t believe I have ever spoke down to you, or anyone I respect on here but I will call out people who can’t back up anything they say with a logical argument or resort to wishing me dead, calling all the expletives under the sun, do the leftie snowflake nonsense etc.

Firstly I completely understand your attitude to those that use foul and abusive language directly at you. Something I experienced, together with ageists rants, from that lovely character, Donegal. If anyone does wish death to anyone on here the Mods should banish them to the naughty step for a few days. As I say, the “speaking down to” me is by association.
Anyway, back to the plot.
So, are you saying previous experience counts for nothing? Why do many on here and countless pundits always suggest that football clubs require players /managers ‘who know the league’ they find themselves in?
You complain about a feeling of disenfranchisement with present British politicians but how do you square that with your love of the Politburo run E.U. where the average person on the street has virtually no say through the ballot box?

Poland still has ‘Homosexual Conversion therapy’ The ruling Law and Justice party says the advancement of gay rights is a “grave danger” to family life. When the coalition that ruled for eight years up till 2015 ignored reforms to LGBT rights it was led by Donald Tusk. Remember him? Romania actively discriminates against its native Roma population.

When were women given universal suffrage in the U.K.? Oh, that’s correct, 1928 with some 8 million plus obtaining the vote in 1918. Portugal not until 1968 Belgium in 1948 and the great democracy of France in 1945. The first Equal Pay Act was passed in the U.K. in 1970! Before at least 14 of the other 27 member states.
Abortion has been legal up to 90 days of pregnancy in Italy and later in cases of ‘severe ‘ abnormalities since 1979 but it is almost impossible to get one. Trainee doctors aren’t even given any tutoring on terminations and GPs are also not educated in contraception. Let’s not forget the recent scandal of the poor women, often victims of rape or familial abuse having to secretly travel to England for treatment from Ireland.

Spain still does not have an independent body to tackle racism. Going on for 50% of Roma and non E.U. migrant children do not complete compulsory education in Spain. Croatia, Hungry, Poland, Serbia and even France do not even have a definition of discrimination in their equality legislation as required by the E.Us. Racial Equality Directive.

Following more Brexit scare predictions (couldn’t be lies because, as we know, only leave supporters resorted to falsehoods) by Dame Grey-Thompson and others about how the U.Ks. Disabled would loose out following Brexit the Papworth Trust, a leading disability charity, says the UK is one of the more progressive of the 28 EU member states when it comes to the treatment of the disabled.
In 1970, the UK passed the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Ac, the first legislation in the world to award rights to disabled people.
From the, E.U. biased, BBCs ‘Fact Checker’ site “E.U. law governs workers' rights, but other areas of social policy are left to the governments of nation states, meaning UK law on disability is by nature more comprehensive than the EU's.”

I think to suggest or infer that The European Union has led the way in enlightenment and that all other Nation Sates were the epitome of liberalism and all sweetness and light in previous eras, compared to Britain, is a little spurious to say the least.

I never said or implied it was the EU that had made it possible for those civil liberties, I was pointing out that nostalgically looking back at pre-EU Britain as a reason / model to wish to go back to isn’t particularly appealing to many. It also proves the point that the EU are not stopping us making our own decisions. 

I don’t like the E.U. as a political body, it clearly has faults but any decision that will potentially make my family worse off I’m against. My son is ten he’s not known school life without austerity measures and yet I’m being told for the greater good he might have to accept more financial upheaval for the sake of Brexit. Fuck that! Why should he? He didn’t cause the financial crash and he didn’t vote for Brexit! 

If you’re comfortable with what is happening, why? What is going to be so much better under a Boris (ffs) Tory government? What his plan?

How about those that did vote for Brexit pay the potential extra on their goods and services? If it proves a costly folly they can subsidise those that didn’t? A kind of Brexit tax / charitable scheme if they believe in the decision so fervently. Say £1000 per person per year for a decade? ;)
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: The world has finally gone to hell in a handcart - by Derek Hardballs - 06-25-2019, 03:39 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)