02-02-2026, 12:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-02-2026, 12:42 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(02-02-2026, 09:14 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(02-02-2026, 09:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(02-02-2026, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It was already broken... It was just slowly falling to pieces. I would still rather us smash it to pieces, try and find a new identity which could work and have a 10 game mini season to save our asses.
The change needs to be from a "vision" perspective. It needs to be firm, unmistakable and not for discussion. Hopefully Nestor and his appointments of Mowbray and Mason were a lesson learned for Patel that not having a firm identity/DNA is damaging. Ur doesn't matter what league we are in, this has to be the absolute minimum we see.
We really don’t need a ‘vision’ at this time, we need a manager to get the best out of the squad they have, get organised, play, players in the positions they understand and give them simple instructions as to what is expected of them individually and collectively. Going down will set the club back years on and off the pitch.
Visions, philosophies are for managers who talk a great game, if you like football management speak, which is getting more cliched every year it seems. We’ve gone from philosophies to visions, DNA and moments and it’s all meaningless drivel. By all means in the future have a preferred way of playing and recruit accordingly but the pseudo intellectual drivel that surrounds football currently is just an endless list of buzz words and catchphrases.
Ramsay came with the reputation of being meticulously organised who got the best out of a bunch of players in Minnesota.
His first game showed real promise, the game v Derby showed grit and determination and a level of ploddy organisation. Then the other 2 games have looked as devoid of a plan or approach as the rest of the year.
I have seen so many suggestions of "going back to basics", "playing a formation that suits the players", "keep things simple". Those are the cliches that make my shit itch. They don't mean anything. They are throw away terms that have no real meaning.
What is basic is having a really clear idea of how we are going to approach a game both in and out of possession, and not once wavering from that between now and the end of the year. What that looks like is anybody guess quite frankly, but the only thing I am certain of is a flat back 4 with no offensive threat and a midfield 2 offering not much more has been proven NOT to work. What's the old saying about insanity?
The weird circle jerk about going back to what has failed all year is one of the most insane things I have ever read on this dump. It's like turkeys voting for Christmas.
The reputation that Ramsay has and the reality of what we have seen so far are miles apart. He came in and decided to completely change how we played, we went from a team that was comfortable if not spectacular in possession to a team that surrendered possession, placing players in positions they aren’t used to and in some cases can’t play. That isn’t a pragmatic approach it’s dogmatic and potentially could see us relegated.
All this talk about DNA, visions etc and in reality all it means is a club setting out a style of play it wants all its team to employ over a sustained period of time. Vic Buckingham was doing this with us and then Barcelona nearly a century ago, just attaching bullshit buzzwords to age old method of working.

