02-02-2026, 11:28 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-02-2026, 11:30 AM by Birdman1811.)
(02-02-2026, 11:18 AM)SeanFlynnsPressUps Wrote: It's weird seeing people say "It's not the system, it's just bad defending" when the defending is a feature of the system. It's not all the system, but if you wanted to design a way of playing that was particularly poorly suited to the current lot of players it would be this one because we have players with things they are good at and things they are bad at and the things they are bad at are hugely exposed in the system.
We were letting in soft goals under Mason because players kept getting caught in posession on the edge of the box and giving the ball away, yes that's bad defending and individual errors, but it was because the players were instructed to play it out at the back, the defenders were instructed to spread wide across the pitch and one midfielder was instructed to drop deep to pick up the ball and it often resulted in a player recieving the ball under pressure on the edge of our box. In the main, this isn't a terrible weakness to have because our midfield and defence are not awful at playing out from the back, but you saw the huge increase in those sort of goals when we switched goalkeepers and suddenly we had to play riskier passes because the goalkeeper didn't have the ability to receive the ball to feet.
Under Ramsey the instruction is to drop into a line of 5 with 4 ahead of them and to restrict the space rather than man marking or making challenges. The instruction is also for that 5-4-1 in defence to become a 3-4-3 in attack which means the wing backs need to cover the entire length of the pitch, the inside forwards need to drop onto the wings and the outside cbs need to tuck in.
On transition half of our team are moving back into position rather than paying attention to the other team and while they drop back we give away a lot of ground to the opposition and let them flood into our third of the pitch. There's a huge space in between the back 5 and the midfield 4 that neither the midfield or the defence are expected to move into and there's a huge weakness in the space between the outside CB and the wing back.
You can see the way the system makes it difficult for us to cope with transitions, and then you can see the instruction to hammer long balls up to Heggebo means we constantly hand the ball over to the other team and end up defending in this really innefective way. I think it's really highlighting the weaknesses in our defence, and we'd be much better off keeping hold of the ball and keeping it out of our third.
+1
Exactly right. The problem is we can retain the ball quite well, just can't do anything positive with it a lot of the time, and we attack best on the counter out wide, which is the exact opposite to how we can defend. Hence I said, how I set us up would be boring, mind numbing, low scoring and frustrating as fuck for fans and anyone watching.

