01-14-2026, 06:09 PM
(01-14-2026, 05:24 PM)Duffers Wrote:(01-14-2026, 04:35 PM)Jacko Wrote: Personally I can forgive the ones we lost when we were established in the top division. Wood, Thorne, Field. They weren't ready and needed to drop down. I can forgive the recent ones we simply had to sell to avoid PSR points deductions (Taylor, Fellows, Palmer to an extent), and I can forgive Rogers, we had to make a deal with City or risk losing him for a development fee.
It's the likes of Azaz and Cleary (I'm sure there's more) who we've lost while we've been back in the Championship and aside from CC's full season, not been doing particularly well in, without giving them any minutes even as an encouragement. It's unforgivable really.
Cleary couldn't get a minute under Bilic, Allardyce, Ismael, Bruce, Corberan or Mowbray. Were they all wrong?
Again, 5 in 22 appearances for a League One side hardly suggests we've let a future superstar slip through our fingers. Don't see the fuss around Cleary to be honest. He'll probably have a perfectly respectable career in the lower leagues but that's about it.
Agree with this.
On the occasions that Cleary did get a chance for our first team he never made any impact at all and looked a fair way off being the ready for first team football despite the rave reviews at youth level. In the several games I saw him for Walsall he looked every bit a player who just isn't going to make it.
It looks as though he's having a level of relative success at Barnsley but as the post above says, it's hardly world beating stats and at almost 22 he's not a really young kid anymore. I've heard interviews with players in the past who have said that the difference in quality between playing at Conference level and then up to League One wasn't actually that great but it was then moving up to the Championship where they noticed a massive difference. If Cleary does get a move up and really starts to impress then maybe it's time for some pant wetting over him but for now I'm not going to be suggesting that the club dropped a clanger with this one.

