01-13-2026, 02:00 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-13-2026, 02:03 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Within such a cash-rich and glamorous industry, I simply don’t understand why so many clubs succumb to the misty-eyed delusion that it will be a great idea to bring back a former playing hero as manager - it seems to go wrong far more often than it works out. Not only is it ignorant of (and therefore biased against) the current managerial stock available, but surely in such a role any perceived club ‘loyalty advantage’ could just as easily give rise to a lack of objectivity. Almost like nepotism less the bloodline.
Generally speaking, in such cases the manager desires the role more than the role desires the manager. Which - unless you’re at the very top (which is definitely not the case, what with Man Utd now out of both cups and a UCL finish being the best possible outcome for the season) - isn’t really healthy. Football is, sadly, a business, and - in demanding the best of a business - the cold hard reality is that, in a way, it is a healthy situation when any appointments (players and staff) excel to the point that they outgrow you. Like a Corberan for example, a Hodgson, or (ironically) even a Dashworth. In all other aspects than that loyalty love-in, from any business perspective the jigsaw pieces just don’t seem to fit.
It’s a shame also, because I don’t actually mind Carrick (he’s supposed to be quite a grounded and nice fella), whereas I despise that club. For his sake I’d rather he’d gone somewhere else to further his career than becoming the next Solskjaer. I’m sure the pay packet will be worth it regardless so my sympathy is of course limited should it all go tits up. Which history suggests that it will.
Generally speaking, in such cases the manager desires the role more than the role desires the manager. Which - unless you’re at the very top (which is definitely not the case, what with Man Utd now out of both cups and a UCL finish being the best possible outcome for the season) - isn’t really healthy. Football is, sadly, a business, and - in demanding the best of a business - the cold hard reality is that, in a way, it is a healthy situation when any appointments (players and staff) excel to the point that they outgrow you. Like a Corberan for example, a Hodgson, or (ironically) even a Dashworth. In all other aspects than that loyalty love-in, from any business perspective the jigsaw pieces just don’t seem to fit.
It’s a shame also, because I don’t actually mind Carrick (he’s supposed to be quite a grounded and nice fella), whereas I despise that club. For his sake I’d rather he’d gone somewhere else to further his career than becoming the next Solskjaer. I’m sure the pay packet will be worth it regardless so my sympathy is of course limited should it all go tits up. Which history suggests that it will.

