(12-31-2025, 08:51 AM)Lightnin Wrote:(12-31-2025, 08:35 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Both men will know more about football than I ever will, I have no problem admitting that.
However, what have both seen in Wildsmith to justify starting him. Does he give a particularly good blow job, perhaps?
I have limited football knowledge, and I accept that, but even I can see Wildsmith is a fucking fraud and should be nowhere near a staring place, so what am I missing?
I suspect Wildsmith is a far better keeper than we think. Regular keeper for a side that won promotion, suggests he has something about him.
As someone asked on a podcast I recently listened to, who is the worst goalkeeper who was first choice goalkeeper for a title winning side.
When you have thought about that question, you'll cone to the conclusion that it is very rare to have a successful season with a bad keeper.
It is true that he had a successful season in the year that Derby won the title but if you check back with Wednesday fans, they all seemed to have the same opinion of him, 66 games in 8 seasons I think he made? I know of a few opposition fans too that were delighted when he was selected against them after seeing him in action.
I don’t think he’s necessarily a bad keeper as like you say, he must have something about him but my opinion is he’s just a bit slow on his reactions which isn’t a good trait for a keeper. Dives after the ball has already gone past, slow with his hands against shots, square with his feet.
Sorry but he is a poor keeper, by all metrics he’s the worst keeper in our division this season.
There is a big step up between League One and the Championship, and there’s no disgrace in being a good League One keeper, however there is a disgrace in continually picking one when you want to be competitive in the Championship, even more so when there’s a goalkeeper with a far higher ceiling currently sitting on the bench despite not really warranting dropping.

