12-26-2025, 09:04 PM
(12-26-2025, 08:55 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:The hands in pockets is a metaphor for his inactivity when things are not going well Josh. If we were top of the league he could be naked with an apple on his gob, no-one would give a shit.(12-26-2025, 08:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:No one knows what is said, or not said, by Mason. I certainly don't. So I can't comment on that, one way or t'other. What I do know is the fact he happens to have his hands in his pockets has sod all to do with anything! I really don't see the relevance - other than the fact some fans don't like seeing it and it's an easy and lazy criticism to make.(12-26-2025, 08:27 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:It’s not about ranting and raving at all and that comment is just as lazy is it not?(12-26-2025, 08:24 PM)Jacko Wrote:(12-26-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I really don't understand the relevance of Mason's touchline demeanor.
The team isn't playing badly and making error after error because the manager has his hands in his pockets, FFS! That's just a lazy comment.
He's passive rather than proactive.
He's reactive to player mistakes. He's like Kevin the Teenager. His demeanour plays into this.
I agree he's not proactive, but disagree his demeanour has anything to do with how our players play.
It's nonsense to bring that into it, it's a lazy comment because some fans want to see a manager ranting and raving and showing some 'pashun'.
Mason isn't that sort of character, and he doesn't need to be.
He has many faults, and fans are right to be critical of him, but how he appears on the touchline shouldn't be used against him.
He gives no direction whatsoever as he is completely silent. Even when there’s a break in play, the players rarely go to him and he doesn’t encourage them to. When we were getting ripped apart down the right today, he did nothing, never spoke to Campbell or MJ, just watched silently.
Then, when he swapped the useless Villa cunt, to use your, very apt expression, for Price, he gave a very basic, one-handed, instruction, the other stayed in his pocket, that lasted about 10 seconds. He then completely blanked Price as he came off.
This is what I mean, when I refer to his demeanour, nothing to do with ranting and raving. Just some evidence that he is watching and seeing what everyone else can see and, maybe, just maybe, reacting to it.
The subs and tactics you point out - you're absolutely spot on, and it's poor from Mason, but again, that has nothing to do with whether he has his hands in his pockets or out of his pockets, or how he stands or acts.
Are we seriously suggesting if Mason stood there with his hands out of his pockets and in some sort of positive body stance (I don't know what that would be, btw) then we'd suddenly see the players play better and make fewer mistakes? We're not, are we?
It makes him look physically scared and his actions, or lack of, compound this. His overall demeanour is reflective of the performance. That’s the point I’m making.
And you are right, you can’t see what he’s saying but you can see when he’s saying nothing.

