11-24-2025, 06:41 PM
(11-24-2025, 05:34 PM)richbaggie Wrote:(11-24-2025, 05:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: And I think I disagree with the adage that football is a simple game that is over complicated - I think fans (and definitely myself amongst others here) overcomplicate with stats to overcompensate for our own experience - but football is a game of marginal gains. Given how important one single goal is, every detail can be controlled and refined, that is where the game rightfully requires complication. The most successful clubs per pound spent are those that complicate the game with set piece coaches, throw in specialists, and use metric upon metric to source players, refine players and improve their outputs.
The speed of the game is immense, and things like body shape, where to position to at the side of opponents, where to set the press, when to trigger and not trigger, which foot to play opponents onto, all of these data points are complications but all breed a competitive advantage on the pitch. Prepping for and altering this in game was what CC did brilliantly, he was light years ahead of so many managers in how he saw, calculated and implemented play, similar to how Roy instilled a tactical discipline that RDM couldn’t dream of.
Mason does not demonstrate an ability to see or do any of this, he is very capable of creating a game plan and implementing it, as shown by how well we approach and generally start games, but he cannot see what’s going on on the pitch and he cannot react to it, which is what sorts a decent training ground coach from a manager.
Agree with the comparisons of Roy and CC and the Mason comment. It shows me that RM can coach but at the moment is struggling with management of games. I think he will get better at this with experience. Using the CC comparison again, he took quite a while to be effective at Huddersfield but they stuck with him and reaped a reward. Will we show the same patience?
While Huddersfield finished 20th under CC, with 51 points, that was only two points fewer and two places lower than the previous season. Plus, this was during the Covid season, so fans weren't at matches. Despite a disastrous second half of the season last year, we still managed to finish 9th, so there's no way fans will settle for finishing in the bottom third of the Championship, especially as it's so weak this year.
There's also the issue of CC being a much more convincing communicator than Mason, who is clearly too used to the soft soaping that interim managers in the PL get. In addition to this, he actually looked like he was going to cry* after the Charlton match and that will have troubled Albion fans, who don't actually like to see someone suffer because they are out of their depth.
Just to add, Coventry fans were very complimentary of our initial set-up (see VftO thread) and claimed Mason had outwitted Lampard. So, I agree, the initial setup and homework on the opposition is good. Charlton away is the best example of the difference between an experienced manager and Mason. Jones knew exactly when to roll the dice and who to bring on. Mason didn't and the end result was obvious.
*Local media were weirdly reluctant to say this openly, which seems odd for our supposedly enlightened times.


