10-29-2025, 06:51 PM
(10-27-2025, 07:24 PM)Fido Wrote: Fuggin Graceland. Loved Simon and Garfunkel but that album was utter pap.
From today's Telegraph. He explains his logic including Lou Reed.
Neil McCormick Chief Music Critic
Why Bridge Over Troubled Water didn’t make my top 50 albums
Simon & Garfunkel’s gorgeous 1970 swansong is a masterpiece, but I stand by my omission
Bridge Over Troubled Water (1970) by Simon & Garfunkel
The duo’s iconic LP ‘takes listeners on a journey of longing, loneliness and spiritual connection’
Troubled Waters have been stirred by my 50 Greatest Albums article. There have been thousands of comments about albums I have underrated or overlooked, but one missing album in particular keeps surfacing – Simon & Garfunkel’s gorgeous 1970 swansong, Bridge Over Troubled Water. It is a resonant masterpiece beloved by millions – myself very much included.
It was the best-selling album of 1970, one of the greatest years in popular music history (outselling the Beatles’ own swansong, Let It Be). It is packed with songs that reach towards the very pinnacle of lyrical and melodic songcraft; that have stood the test of time, richly arranged and sensitively performed by two of the finest singers you could ever hope to hear.
So why (to paraphrase many irate readers) did it not appear in my all-time top 50? To be fair, even my editor seemed aghast at its exclusion and has requested that I explain myself.
Well, it is not because I forgot about it. I am a huge fan of Paul Simon, who I have interviewed four times (and Art Garfunkel twice). I rank Simon very highly among the greatest singer-songwriters to have ever lived, and though I might personally love Bob Dylan more for his sheer originality, panache, depth and invention, I think Simon and Joni Mitchell are probably the greatest ever when it comes to marrying literary lyrics of poetic resonance with melodies, harmonies and rhythms of corresponding richness and complexity. And Simon beats Mitchell hands down if you throw hooks and hits into the mix.
But from the moment I sketched out possible titles to include in my top 50, I put a question mark next to Simon’s name: Troubled Water or Graceland? What, in other words, is Paul Simon’s own greatest accomplishment? And I stand by my choice of Graceland, his most successful solo album from 1986, a 16-million-selling masterpiece of wit, passion and spirited delight, that audaciously blends the sounds of southern Africa with roots grooves of the USA.
Although controversial at the time (because Simon broke a cultural boycott of apartheid South Africa to make his masterpiece), it had a huge effect on popularising what we used to call World Music, and bringing in a whole panoply of influences that have continued to percolate through western pop.
Within its unique synthesis of sounds, it contained some of the most outrageously brilliant songs that have ever been heard: The Boy in the Bubble, Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes and You Can Call Me Al. I ranked it at 41 in my top 50 and received no complaints. I suppose the question that the always rather sensitive Art Garfunkel might pose is: why couldn’t I find space for Bridge Over Troubled Water too?
But by some estimates there have been as many as 10 million albums released since the dawn of the era of the long-playing record. And 10 million into 50 just won’t go. So early in the process, I made a decision to only include one album by key artists, with the exception of Bob Dylan (who had two) and the Beatles (three), because to me they are the twin godheads of modern popular music.
For Lou Reed, I wrote down Transformer and The Velvet Underground & Nico. For Joni Mitchell, the choice was Hejira or Blue. For Pink Floyd, it was Dark Side of the Moon versus Wish You Were Here.
By the time I had sketched out an initial shortlist, it ran to well over 200 albums, and I knew I had hard choices to make.
I deeply love Bridge Over Troubled Water. It opens with perhaps the most mystically gorgeous ballad ever written, and takes listeners on a journey of longing, loneliness and spiritual connection, with quite a bit of wit and humour sprinkled in there too on songs now embedded in the psyche of the world, including Cecilia, The Boxer, Baby Driver and El Cóndor Pasa (If I Could). But it operated within parameters being explored by many of Simon & Garfunkel’s contemporaries, including the Beatles, Mitchell, Dylan, Brian Wilson, Neil Young, Randy Newman and Carole King.
The same questing spirit and musical and lyrical ingenuity is still present 16 years later on Graceland, but on that album, Simon was creating music the likes of which no one had ever heard before. That’s why Graceland gets my vote.

