(09-03-2025, 12:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Lurker - you've been told what the test involves. It's not difficult.
The fact that Khalef doesn't want the test is clear indication of what the test is for: chromosomes. If you have XY chromosomes, you will not be allowed to compete in female sports unless there is compelling evidence otherwise.
And yes, we all know that there is massive variance in human physiology. Not everyone is born with one thumb and four fingers on each hand, yet I don't see anyone crying to glove manufacturers.
Your original post spoke volumes. Concern for Imane Khelif, concern for the sports authorities. None whatsoever for the women who have lost out on medals and have been endangered.
You can subsequently wave about whatever other credentials you choose. That omission speaks volumes.
Either you want to protect women's sport for women, or you don't. In the latter case, you end up with women facing a male boxer and an Olympic women's 800m final where gold, silver and bronze all go to athletes with XY chromosomes (Rio 2016). Hence why the IAAF is also bringing in genetic testing Btw, the other competitors in that race were all called cry baby drama queens too. Nobody was concerned about them until it was far too late to make a difference.
Not sure my concerns for a women being excluded from competition and an organisation having to take such upsetting decisions is in anyway an indication of my lack of allyship towards women.
In fact it couldn't be any further from the truth for me personally. I am a white ribbon ambassador in the campaign against violence towards women and girls now. Before that I was coach for the GB girls shotokan karate team amongst other things within martial arts.
But, regarding the test, I am not talking about what the physical test is. I am dubious about the testing parameters, and whether it will actually protect women's competition in the way I, and I know you want. As I say, the body of scientific literature in this area isn't particularly robust at the moment so I wouldn't like to nail my colours to the mast with an opinion.
Fwiw, if a governing body was to say. We are not allowing any person to compete in women's categories unless they are female, genetically, gonadal and anatomically and have current testosterone levels of below 5 nmol/L. I wouldn't particularly kick up a stink for the time being as it is a reasonable thing to do for competitive integrity.
It does not however mean that it is the best course of action in the long run as it will likely stop XX chromosome people from competing too.
"IMO of course..."

