Women's Boxing
#16
(09-03-2025, 10:07 AM)Squid Wrote: As set out in the links provided, the testing is either a blood test or cheek swab. So not hugely invasive and not excessively expensive either.

The alternative is women being punched in the face by people with male strength, either due to a disorder of sexual development or under previous IOC rules, which went on the information in someone's passport, because they actually were born and registered as male before changing gender.

Generally, rules are not made around edge cases. They are made to protest the majority. In the vast, vast majority of cases there is clear, blue water between male and female sporting ability. Saying "Oh, but what about..?" to muddy the waters does not benefit women's sport.

A blood test is invasive, Squid, a swab not much. But in terms of expense. It's not just the test, it's the admin, record keeping, GDPR, enforcement etc. For many amature sports it is completely unmanageable

Whilst I completely agree that there are clear disparities between Men and Women across the board in terms of their athletic abilities and I wouldn't want the average Jenny being lamped in the face by an average John. The difficulty, and muddiness comes in the classification of sex. Sex isn't as binary as many believe and is in 3 classifications; genetic, gonadal and anatomic. 

Testosterone tends to be the thing that most focus on as during puberty, higher levels of testosterone is what leads to natural increased physical performance. But this doesnt completely lie in line with my point above about different conditions regardless of genetic differences. 

Bluntly speaking, when does a women become a man? Any line drawn is going to be arbitrary and up for debate and frankly our understanding of DSDs and intersex peoples sporting advantage is lacking. 

In terms of women sports, sorting out the non physiological stuff would be a better use of resource and effort. Driving more engagement, removing barriers to competition, increasing funding and media exposure. These will not only benefit all women in sport by decreasing the performance gap, but allow us to  critically analyse and understand the effects of things like DSDs and other hormonal issues in isolation. That would allow better, more productive discussions and a more complete and rounded approach to policy making.

(09-03-2025, 10:27 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If she's previously registered and competed as a male then I'm not sure there is any further argument to say she should be allowed to compete in women's sport.

Wasn't aware of some of this in my earlier postings, hence the questions. Every day is a school day.

She hasn't Ted. Born, a women, lived as a women, competed as a women. 

But a genetic test in 2023 allegedly questioned her ability to compete based on 'Gender Eligibility Criteria'.

There is no where near enough clarity and transparency about what type of test is being mandated and what the criterias are. That's the big issue. 

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/crlr8gp813ko

Another decent article outlining the scientific difficulties policy makers are facing.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 07:15 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 07:18 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by MrBater - 09-03-2025, 07:31 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 07:37 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 07:43 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 09:02 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 07:58 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by MrBater - 09-03-2025, 08:09 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 08:15 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 08:26 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 08:32 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by GunsOfNavarone - 09-03-2025, 08:34 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 09:52 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 10:07 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 10:37 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 10:27 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 12:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 12:48 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 03:44 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 04:10 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 04:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 04:54 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 04:31 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-03-2025, 05:07 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 05:13 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 05:34 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 05:45 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 05:49 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 06:43 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 07:50 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-03-2025, 08:58 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 09:06 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-03-2025, 09:24 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 09:06 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 09:55 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Shabby Russian - 09-04-2025, 07:21 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-04-2025, 05:55 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-04-2025, 07:08 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by HawkingsHalfpint - 09-04-2025, 07:38 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-04-2025, 08:31 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Shabby Russian - 09-04-2025, 09:12 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by AnelkasBeard - 09-04-2025, 08:39 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 10:16 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-04-2025, 09:22 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Shabby Russian - 09-04-2025, 09:52 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by AnelkasBeard - 09-04-2025, 10:29 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 11:12 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by CarlosCorbewrong - 09-04-2025, 11:54 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 12:30 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-04-2025, 12:40 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Tom Joad - 09-04-2025, 10:29 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 01:18 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 03:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 05:16 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 05:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 07:46 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 08:18 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-04-2025, 10:09 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: