Women's Boxing
#12
(09-03-2025, 07:43 AM)Squid Wrote:
(09-03-2025, 07:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The difficulty in these situations is finding the hill to die on


Do we do parameter testing and say you have to fit into certain physical characteristic bands? E.g. certain limb length, bone density, lung capacity , heart capacity. As we do for weight in boxing for example. Or do they do sex assigned at birth as the decider?

I am sure it was confirmed that Khalif was female at birth but had a degree of intersexed characteristics.

Such a difficult one for not only her but the sport too.

Unlike that fella who swims.

Only on the first page and somebody is still trying the Phelps gambit.

This is why I wanted to find the old thread, because I'd actually gone to the bother of posting the times from a good medal race for Phelps v the equivalent women's competition.

Here they are again:

Results from the final
Rank Lane Name Nationality Time Notes
1st place, gold medalist(s) 5 Michael Phelps United States 50.58 OR
2nd place, silver medalist(s) 4 Milorad Čavić Serbia 50.59 ER
3rd place, bronze medalist(s) 3 Andrew Lauterstein Australia 51.12 OC
4 6 Ian Crocker United States 51.13
5 2 Jason Dunford Kenya 51.47
6 1 Takuro Fujii Japan 51.50 AS
7 7 Andriy Serdinov Ukraine 51.59
8 8 Ryan Pini Papua New Guinea 51.86


Final
Rank Lane Name Nationality Time Notes
1st place, gold medalist(s) 4 Lisbeth Trickett Australia 56.73 OC
2nd place, silver medalist(s) 5 Christine Magnuson United States 57.10
3rd place, bronze medalist(s) 3 Jessicah Schipper Australia 57.25
4 2 Zhou Yafei China 57.84
5 6 Tao Li Singapore 57.99
6 7 Jemma Lowe Great Britain 58.06
7 8 Gabriella Silva Brazil 58.10
8 1 Inge Dekker Netherlands 58.54

As is clear for all to see, the difference between the male and female times is vast. Hence we have separate sporting competitions for males and females.

Also, I'd add the people this is most difficult for are the women who were 1)Punched in the face by someone with male strength and 2)Denied a fair sporting competition and losing out on the opportunity of a career defining and life-changing gold medal. I imagine that would be pretty difficult too.

I am not trying the "Phelps Gambit", squid. I am trying to find the point where the governing bodies of sports around the world can restrict certain individuals access to competition. 

As somebody who has completed at world level in Martial arts, I understand more than most the devastating impact contact sports can have on individuals and the need to regulate competition accordingly. 

There are two main issues I see here in relation to 'genetic testing' being used instead of sex assigned at birth they are;

Consistency - For this to be rolled out it would have to be done for any organised, elite level sport from early teens onwards as it is then that most intersex individuals begin to notice that their bodies are developing differently. This would not only be invasive it would be a huge logistical operation costing far more than most amateur sports can afford. If it wasn't conducted as a blanket approach you would then fall into the muddy waters of judging a persons level of 'femininity' based on societal standards of height, beauty and body type, messy indeed. 

Thresholds - What are the thresholds? I know you'll say it's the "Phelps Gambit" again. But a women with Swyer Syndrome and an XY chromosome,  and one with congenital adrenal hyperplasia and an XX chromosome may have similar levels of sex hormones throughout puberty, and have similar advantages physically there after. You would never really know who had what chromosomes, unless we go down the route of what I explained above. 

As a Sports Scientist by trade I find this really interesting but as a former junior elite athlete I really appreciate competitive integrity and the safety of competitors. 

Tricky indeed.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 07:15 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 07:18 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by MrBater - 09-03-2025, 07:31 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 07:37 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 07:43 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 09:02 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 07:58 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by MrBater - 09-03-2025, 08:09 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 08:15 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 08:26 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 08:32 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by GunsOfNavarone - 09-03-2025, 08:34 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 09:52 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 10:07 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 10:37 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 10:27 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 12:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 12:48 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 03:44 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 04:10 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 04:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 04:54 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 04:31 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-03-2025, 05:07 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 05:13 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 05:34 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-03-2025, 05:45 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 05:49 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-03-2025, 06:43 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 07:50 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-03-2025, 08:58 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 09:06 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-03-2025, 09:24 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025, 09:06 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-03-2025, 09:55 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Shabby Russian - 09-04-2025, 07:21 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-04-2025, 05:55 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-04-2025, 07:08 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by HawkingsHalfpint - 09-04-2025, 07:38 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-04-2025, 08:31 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Shabby Russian - 09-04-2025, 09:12 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by AnelkasBeard - 09-04-2025, 08:39 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 10:16 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Jacko - 09-04-2025, 09:22 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Shabby Russian - 09-04-2025, 09:52 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by AnelkasBeard - 09-04-2025, 10:29 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 11:12 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by CarlosCorbewrong - 09-04-2025, 11:54 AM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 12:30 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Ted Maul - 09-04-2025, 12:40 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Tom Joad - 09-04-2025, 10:29 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 01:18 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 03:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 05:16 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 05:28 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Squid - 09-04-2025, 07:46 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Lurker#3 - 09-04-2025, 08:18 PM
RE: Women's Boxing - by Sliced - 09-04-2025, 10:09 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)