06-11-2025, 02:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2025, 03:03 PM by AnelkasBeard.)
(06-11-2025, 01:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(06-11-2025, 10:26 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: No, I'm blaming pure, unadulterated greed from all involved, of which landlords are a clear symptom. And most landlords are unscrupulous and unempathetic, and due to the system that has been created, are allowed and almost incentivised to continue to pump their wealth at the expense of others. How else do you create systematic change to benefit the wider population?
You speak from the obvious privileged position of someone who has plenty of money and is acting in his own self interest, which is precisely the problem I outlined originally.
You speak about investments and pensions, and "oh no they're trying to attack our already large sums of money" - whilst most people in the country are just trying to get through each month making sure they've managed to pay all their bills and fed themselves and their family. You appear very out of touch, unsurprisingly.
My dad was a toolmaker (really).
I cleaned paint out of the drains at Jaguar, I served tea wearing a straw boater at New St Station, I went to a Polytechnic, I worked in a Homelessness & Welfare Benefits Team at a Midlands City Council, I took and paid for professional qualifications in my own time, I left a job at another Council for less money and fewer benefits to get into the career I wanted to, I brought forward coalfield sites that created more clean, safe jobs than had ever existed down the pit, I built several million more sq ft of commercial property across the UK, I founded my first business in the depths of the GFC, I founded my second and third businesses during Covid.
My overriding priority is to provide for my family. Part of the diverse portfolio of assets that I have acquired from taxed income, taxed investment income or borrowing over the years are a few properties that I rent out at market rents. I clean out drains, I put up fences, I replace the floor and ceiling that tenants manage to flood in a drunken stupor.
I don't consider myself greedy, unscrupulous or unempathetic. Just someone who is trying to do the right thing by the people who matter most to me.
You seem to believe [enlightened] self interest is a problem, when it's actually the foundation of every successful society.
If you get in a rage at people like me you're simply ignoring the actual culprits. It's bordering on Trumpian / Faragian to blame landlords for the complete and utter state of the property. market.
I'll take your word that you're one of the "good landlords" as I've no reason to think otherwise, but for every one of you and Birdie's landlord, there are tens out there that couldn't give less of a fuck about tenants and seem to treat them as a sub class of people, simply as their cash cow. I've experienced this first hand on at least 5 occasions when renting in my 20s (luckily I didn't have a family at the time so I was much more able to move around), and sadly once in my 30s, with my family. Many of my friends have plenty of other similar experiences.
The problem with our debate is that you're approaching from your viewpoint as a landlord, and I am from my viewpoint of a tenant, and I'm aware that I'm probably too entrenched in my views (thanks to personal experiences) for us to make any headway on common ground. My true annoyance comes when people are incapable of seeing the viewpoint of the working class and "middle class" (I use quote-marks because the middle class is being eroded into non-existence), who are stuck in this cycle with little to no hope of escaping, and I'd like to think you're not one of those people.
My point about self interest probably needs to be nuanced more by saying "self interest to excess and the direct detriment of others". Of course you will be looking out for you and yours, but plenty of people take it to extremes when they simply don't need to.
(06-11-2025, 02:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Look up the definition of Enlightened Self Interest then come back to me. There’s no successful society in the world that doesn’t operate on this basis, you can’t look after others unless you first look after yourself.
I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.

