Just to recap:
I suggested raising PA
You suggested that would leave a massive hole in tax revenue (£50bn)
I showed you where the last time the PA was raised it led to a year on year increase in tax revenue (as opposed to the reduction you stated) - I know this is simplistic due to the many factors however the point that the tax revenues wouldn't drop stands.
You talked about something else and bought VAT into it. I agree that we shouldn't increase VAT, however more spending capacity would create more VAT revenue.
I suggested raising PA
You suggested that would leave a massive hole in tax revenue (£50bn)
I showed you where the last time the PA was raised it led to a year on year increase in tax revenue (as opposed to the reduction you stated) - I know this is simplistic due to the many factors however the point that the tax revenues wouldn't drop stands.
You talked about something else and bought VAT into it. I agree that we shouldn't increase VAT, however more spending capacity would create more VAT revenue.

