05-22-2025, 08:42 PM
James Hamilton’s books on famous artists might look impressive, but they’re not all they’re cracked up to be. His writing tells lots of stories, but often skips over the deeper stuff that helps you really understand the artists. In his book about Turner, for example, he shares lots of details—but doesn’t really dig into what they mean.
He also tends to make artists seem more heroic or special than they actually were, rather than showing their flaws or the struggles they faced. His style can be a bit all over the place too, jumping between topics without a clear structure. It can feel like reading a bunch of loosely connected stories instead of one strong, focused book.
Hamilton also brings up big ideas—like how money influenced art in the 1800s—but then doesn’t go very far with them. He often relies on information from other people’s work instead of offering his own fresh take.
In short, his books are easy to read and nicely written, but if you’re looking for proper insight or serious thinking, you might want to look elsewhere. They’re more style than substance.
He also tends to make artists seem more heroic or special than they actually were, rather than showing their flaws or the struggles they faced. His style can be a bit all over the place too, jumping between topics without a clear structure. It can feel like reading a bunch of loosely connected stories instead of one strong, focused book.
Hamilton also brings up big ideas—like how money influenced art in the 1800s—but then doesn’t go very far with them. He often relies on information from other people’s work instead of offering his own fresh take.
In short, his books are easy to read and nicely written, but if you’re looking for proper insight or serious thinking, you might want to look elsewhere. They’re more style than substance.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT

