05-09-2025, 02:57 PM
(05-09-2025, 02:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:(05-09-2025, 01:31 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: From treatment to prevention (noting that the NHS has a limited role in determining population health - that is led by factors outside of the NHS such as employment, nutrition, social inclusion, primary mental health, environment etc). Note, prevention - in most medical conditions except maternity - takes years or decades to realise benefits so a degree of double running costs are unavoidable.
Hospital to community (if only the last Labour government hadn't built loads of hospitals on 40 year mortgages and if only the last Tory government hadn't allowed the decimation of primary and community care)
Analogue to Digital.
It's pretty shambolic if we've reached 2025 and those are the three things that would transform the NHS - without going full Proth, any other business would have ceased to function years ago if it was so poorly ran. Still, here we are. Let's see what the grown-ups can cook up.
As I said, prevention - in the primary sense - isn't the NHS's bag. They don't create jobs, fix your diet,stop you from drinking 8 pints every night... I don't think it's well positioned to do that.
If it had been, however, a combination of the 2 matters below - both central government policy under Blair - has meant that secondary care providers have been DISINCENTIVIZED to avoid demand.
1. A payment system ("payment by results") which rewards a hospital if it sees more patients.
2. A Foundation Trust/PFI model which has meant that income generation has been a necessity in order to keep the lights on.
Whilst you're quite right to point out that it's ridiculous it's worth remembering that the NHS wears 3 hats in this instance but is constrained by the model dictated by politicians:
1. It provides services
2. It pays another part of itself to provide those services but not to reduce demand and if it doesn't manage to pay enough the PFI agreement breaches
3. It is the enforcement arm of the government to make it all work.
That's not a carte blanche defence of it all - but they're hugely important factors.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT

