Do I need to read the whole agreement to get an understanding of double taxation?
The insinuation that it’s more expensive to hire British workers seems quite the general statement, as if it means to convey that any company could simply use any Indian national to do a job and it would be cheaper.
1stly the double taxation only applies to Indian parent companies that second workers into the UK to do a job. The company will pay the UK taxes as per any worker, it is the employee that now won’t have to pay tax in both countries.
2ndly do you think that these companies would feel they can ship over a load of staff because it is cheaper to fly them around the world, house them for x years and then pay them below market rate?
You still haven’t answered if you think this applies to all companies?
The incentive is for companies like TATA to further invest in the UK. I’ve spent 20 years working for Indian, Japanese and American company’s UK operations and seen 1st hand how seconded staff are used - it isn’t to replace the general workforce.
And, although this isn’t quite as straight forward as it sounds, it isn’t the company that saves the tax element, it’s the individual.
The insinuation that it’s more expensive to hire British workers seems quite the general statement, as if it means to convey that any company could simply use any Indian national to do a job and it would be cheaper.
1stly the double taxation only applies to Indian parent companies that second workers into the UK to do a job. The company will pay the UK taxes as per any worker, it is the employee that now won’t have to pay tax in both countries.
2ndly do you think that these companies would feel they can ship over a load of staff because it is cheaper to fly them around the world, house them for x years and then pay them below market rate?
(05-07-2025, 06:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(05-07-2025, 05:50 AM)baggy1 Wrote: All employers?
Edit: Maybe I should have phrased that as ‘Any employers?’
I am surprised that the usual financial experts haven’t been on here explaining it tbh
It doesn’t surprise me that you fail to understand how incentives work. Just watch what happens.
You still haven’t answered if you think this applies to all companies?
The incentive is for companies like TATA to further invest in the UK. I’ve spent 20 years working for Indian, Japanese and American company’s UK operations and seen 1st hand how seconded staff are used - it isn’t to replace the general workforce.
And, although this isn’t quite as straight forward as it sounds, it isn’t the company that saves the tax element, it’s the individual.

