(05-28-2019, 07:24 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:(05-28-2019, 02:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Whatever style suits the players we have. There is no need for the worst of Pulis displays, but unless we have an amazing overhaul, we can't be a possession dominating, attacking team either.
You are probably right but plenty were saying we had the best squad in the champ (and some that we should piss the league) yet at the same time suggested we cant take champ teams on football wise and attack them. If we have the better squad (or more importantly better first 11) we can and should at this level and should not be afraid to. We were as successful as at any point this season early on when we scored lots despite conceding sloppy goals. It was when the goals stopped flowing we stalled.
But I think the limitations of the squad were clearer to those who correctly predicted a play off spot, and the play off zone was where we spent most of the season - so Moore and Shan did as well as they could - our players in the end could not dominate so called lesser teams consistently enough to stay in the top 2.
We still have a squad that can be up there though and we were not that far off points wise at the end of the season - so I would like to think we will get a coach who believes that squad is good enough to dominate games and attack championship teams- and convince the players they are. That doesn't mean not being tidy at the back and improving with less risk taking - but no excuse for us at this level if genuine contenders with a good squad of near prem quality players not to be attack minded.
The fear is some of those players are not really as good as they or we think - else they need an attitude transplant.
We do not have a squad that can be up there - at the moment. We've lost 10/11 players already with more to follow.
At the moment I think we can only be sure of this as our starting 11;
Johnstone
Wilson
O'Shea
Bartley
Gibbs (??)
Edwards
Field
Livermore
Brunt
Phillips
Kanu.
(05-28-2019, 08:38 PM)Squid Wrote:(05-28-2019, 08:07 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Its a fallacious argument to me to suggest we had the best squad in the championships, but it was limited to 'playing to its strengths' and cant dominate a game and could only really play counter attack. This approach came up short against some of the teams above and around us later in the season, and if our players/squad was better than the rest, it should have been able to do more.
We didn't play to our strengths though. That's the issue. We had a good shot-stopping goalkeeper and three big burly defenders, but we made them pass it out from the back instead. This meant we leaked goals and we're always on the back foot.
Jones should be crucified.
(05-28-2019, 09:04 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(05-28-2019, 09:00 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:(05-28-2019, 08:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(05-28-2019, 08:19 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:(05-28-2019, 08:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The argument is sound. You wouldn’t get the best out of Man City’s squad asking them to play direct / long ball football, you wouldn’t get the best out the title winning Leicester team playing open, possession based football. If a squad has been built to play one way then play that way.Why would you build a squad to play only one way - not to be able to play football and dominate weaker teams? A stupid thing to do and a danger that you can never change or adapt and get stuck for ideas. If your players are better footballers let them show it.
You’re still playing football whether you are “dominating” teams or not. In practice Leicester didn’t dominate most team all the way to the title. Wolves didn’t change how they played last season, Chelsea won the Champions league whilst getting dominated by the opposition on a number of occasions.
Playing to a teams strengths isn’t stupid trying to make players do things they aren’t comfortable with is.
Its just soundbites though - "playing to strengths". If you have a much better squad of players, why play counter attack and not go on the offensive? What do you do when you go a goal down or play a team that wants to counter attack you? A good team can adapt and isnt stuck with one approach - if your strengths are that one dimensional you are not strong. Its making excuses for players not actually being that good, especially when dropping from the prem to the champ. They were maybe built for one approach which was stupid and to the club's detriment.
Totally, but my point is always build degemce FIRST. Then work on attack.
Always knew degemce was the answer!

