05-04-2025, 12:29 PM
(05-04-2025, 10:41 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:(05-03-2025, 09:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(05-03-2025, 09:07 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:(05-03-2025, 08:57 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: So Labour losing votes to all other parties. They haven't even been in power for a year yet. Whoever would have thought that a centrist dad approach would fail so quickly.
Labour needs to start delivering, and fast, otherwise it's pretty obvious what's coming in 2029.
If they deliver to one side they lose votes on the other and vice versa. Both sides either lent them a temporary vote or refused to vote Tory last year. The delivery everyone speaks of is different things to different people. For some it’s stopping migration, for others it’s increasing welfare. Point remains the same as was made yday - we are a society that doesn’t like the truth
As for Reform, watching some of these councils function made up entirely of new councillors with no experiences will be entertaining and I’m glad it’s not my locality
You sit in the centre of a road, don’t be surprised if you get run over. Particularly when the driver has no real conviction where he wants to go, so currently veers to the right.
Just for clarity Labour are looking to cut £5bn from Welfare to the sick and disabled, that’s why people are against it, they aren’t arguing for more. As for the truth, well for working class voters it looks like the only people who are genuinely affected by Labour policies negatively are the poorest in society… I wonder why they turn to other party’s. Labour like telling the truth to the poor because it’s easy as they have no voice or power to fight back.
This is another example of the messaging. Screaming cuts to welfare of £5b sounds callous and uncaring. But what if this is achieved entirely by supporting disabled people back into work? Who wouldn't want that? That was the message I took from the PIP proposals. I can understand why people receiving these benefits are anxious but (a) nothing has been decided yet and (b) when/if applied, they may actually find themselves enriched both financially and personal worth. Believe me, if the proposals do make things worse for the weak, I won't be voting for them in 4 years time. But at least give them a couple of years to put things right
They are cuts, they can be dressed up anyway that Labour want but they are cuts. They aren’t even releasing the impact assessment before the voting on the proposals/policy, how can anyone make an informed decision without knowing what the proposals will mean to those it will affect?
Many of the people who receive PIP work, it’s not an out of work benefit it’s to help people live as normal life as others take for granted, that includes getting to work, help at work and help just with day to day tasks.
By all means make it easier for those with disabilities to work, but where are the proposals and support for companies to employ people with additional needs? Are the government going to give grants to companies to make their business’s accessible? Given that companies are saying the current system simply doesn’t work, why are they pushing for reforms without any credible plan? The research and systems should be working first, but this is first and foremost about cutting the budget by billions of pounds to plug the gap in Reeves budget.
Look at any credible disability organisation’s own assessments of the proposals, they are all highly critical of them, and they all say they will make people poorer.
I’m all for reforming a poor system but these are proposals along with snooping on disabled people’s bank accounts are callous and simply about cutting the budget. I think I’d have more respect if they were just honest and said as much.

