03-16-2025, 10:14 AM
Deflation is worse than every form of inflation, it creates doom loops by withdrawal of investment, that would have been disastrous for the UK given our stagnant growth.
There was also a need to lower rates post-Brexit for that exact reason above - there was extreme uncertainty and that risked collapsing investment and there needed to be a stimulation package to prevent that. You're arguing from a position that there would be no negative consequences from the vote to leave when the reason there was limited fallout is because of the monetary response, 2016 and 2017 growth rates were hardly good so can you imagine how bad it would have been if they had collapsed due to investment dropping?
And Carney had his hands tied by stupid fiscal policy, if Osborne wasn't such a peanut and relaxed public investment restrictions into infrastructure then inflation would have risen and that would have given room for rate rises but that did not happen. Over his entire tenure at the BoE inflation averaged at 1.4% per year which is comfortably below the target of 2% - and that factors in the time period covering the post-Brexit vote spike and temporarily higher target inflation rate. The very fact that Carney was agitating publicly about wanting to raise rates should growth be sufficient to enable rate rises and the very fact he did raise rates before anyone else when at the BoC which was extremely successful spells out that he is not dovish on raising interest rates.
There was also a need to lower rates post-Brexit for that exact reason above - there was extreme uncertainty and that risked collapsing investment and there needed to be a stimulation package to prevent that. You're arguing from a position that there would be no negative consequences from the vote to leave when the reason there was limited fallout is because of the monetary response, 2016 and 2017 growth rates were hardly good so can you imagine how bad it would have been if they had collapsed due to investment dropping?
And Carney had his hands tied by stupid fiscal policy, if Osborne wasn't such a peanut and relaxed public investment restrictions into infrastructure then inflation would have risen and that would have given room for rate rises but that did not happen. Over his entire tenure at the BoE inflation averaged at 1.4% per year which is comfortably below the target of 2% - and that factors in the time period covering the post-Brexit vote spike and temporarily higher target inflation rate. The very fact that Carney was agitating publicly about wanting to raise rates should growth be sufficient to enable rate rises and the very fact he did raise rates before anyone else when at the BoC which was extremely successful spells out that he is not dovish on raising interest rates.

