(03-09-2025, 09:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’.
If that’s the ‘positive change you’re arguing this current government is making I’d argue you’re talking bollocks.
But that's not a Labour government decision.
That's the indefensible decision of some civil servant. It's why the civil service needs root and branch reform, and why both the tax and benefits systems need simplification.
(03-09-2025, 10:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry TGD, my problem with Labour is they are taking easy options when it comes to cutting budgets by picking on and using the same rhetoric as the Tories. If the leaked planned cuts to the welfare budget for the disabled are true, then it penalises not only those who are genuinely fiddling the system but also those who no matter what ‘incentives’ are offered are incapable of work. Now of course the leaked planned cuts may be to soften up the electorate and then suddenly declare they aren’t going to do that but the fact it’s even mooted that to save money you go after the most vulnerable people in society and those that care for them as a political choice, rather than say go after those avoiding paying tax is wrong on every level. The disabled community and the organisations that support them feel like they are being victimised and bullied by a Labour government who are not making ‘difficult or pragmatic’ choices, they are making lazy and blunderbust choices because those they effect cannot fight back.
I agree with you on that, though the means testing of the WFA wasn't easy - though completely right in economic and moral terms.
I you believe the Tory propaganda on housing allocations being taken out of local hands then that's also a difficult decision - though completely right in economic and moral terms.
I'll believe Labour is serious about welfare reform when they ditch the triple lock and apply NI to pension income over the State Pension.


