The View from the Opposition - Oxford United
#6
(02-23-2025, 04:44 PM)Squid Wrote: It's fair to say that the Oxford forum draws a slightly different crowd compared to Millwall's last week. Amid a squabble about Rowettball, someone even quoted Nietzsche. I've added views on Phillips as I thought it might be on interest, plus one comment because it reminded me of our forum on a matchday. Enjoy:

WBA home are good. Draw for us would be a good result however we do need to find some wins before too long. 0-0 for me. Lots of huff and puff but no goals.

West Brom have won 2, drawn 1 and lost 3 in their 6 while we have won 1, drawn 3 and lost 2. They aren't to be feared and a win isn't out of the question. Would I take a point? Absolutely because right now, every point is 1 point closer to safety and we need 9 of them from the next 14 games.

It might be the ideal time to play the Baggies with their recent drop in form and injury to Jed Wallace.

Not a big miss for them; mostly used off the bench this season with minimal impact. Fellows has kept him out of the team.

I think that he has been playing more under Mowbray who seems to rate him.

Although they're clinging on to the last playoff spot they aren't in great form, however it's better than ours.

I’m no fan of his performances so far, but it wouldn’t surprise me to see Matty Phillips get a good chunk of game time on Saturday. I imagine he’ll be itching to score against his former club.

Baggies are going into this with a fair amount of pressure and expectation on their shoulders after some iffy recent performances. Playing a side who've only conceded 3 in their last 6 away games under Rowett will be on their minds I'm sure.

If we can keep it tight and ugly till the hour mark things could open up in a way that suits us. Wouldn't be surprised to see us rinse and repeat on the core shape with Matos, Mills and Romeny saved for the last 30. The absence of Jed Wallace is a big plus.

West Broms home record this season won 7 drawn 8 lost 2

Of course we are the new boys in this league and the baggies have had some serious money, sloshing around for a considerable time.
On the face of it you would think that they are stronger in every department but it does seem that in many of these higher profile clubs, their form is unpredictable.
We only have to find them on an off day and we can nick the points. Boing boing so to speak!!

Feels like it could be a last chance for Phillips starting here as I'd have personally liked to see any of Mills, RR or Dembele picked ahead of him.
Against his old side mind, so hopefully shows up wanting to prove a point.

Battle of the boilers today, Ideal v Baxi.

They opened us up with ease

So simple.

No need for Mowatt to do that.

Always liked Mowatt, until today.

Exactly. What a tit.

Going to be a drubbing watching this

Their commentators are taking the p**s but they’re right

Haha yeah, the country bumpkin thinks they are Brazil, it's just us being us rubbish making them look good.

Going to be a long afternoon. Mystified why Phillips started?

We're dropping off so much when they get the ball. You would think that'd make us more solid, but we're not tracking the runners and players seem to have eternity to pick a pass. So we're already getting overrun, even with every player behind the ball.

WBA are a class above. It’ll be a long afternoon with the odds stacked against us

What was it they just said? “ this could be a cricket score “ “ men against boys “

West Brom's pressing is very impressive.

The worrying thing is, WBA haven’t even got out of 1st gear yet!

Why does he play Phillips, he's awful.

Philips is up there with Steve Anthrobus levels of terribleness…..

It’s a long way to go however that’s just more minutes for WBA to score more goals!

Mowatt you cnut

Good job this isn't the boat race ,it's like we are paddling and they've got a motor .

we're still in the game against a side that draws a lot of games

I can see why Rowett picked Phillips. Without Leigh we don’t have a guy who can stay wide and win headers as an out-ball for Jamie Cumming - and theoretically Phillips is that physical presence out wide to do that. But it hasn’t worked. He’s won zero headers, seems to be bypassed constantly when defending and is contributing nothing when he has the ball. It’s really hard because we’re sitting deep, getting a bit of a footballing lesson and clinging on for dear life

Pfffff. Blimey. They’re a good side but we’re a long, long way off it.

Phillips has won 2 out of his 3 aerial duels - that’s a stat, not my memory. Besides one horrific pass across to Kioso I think he’s been OK and had some moments in combination with Romeny.

Phillips is finished and can’t see how he anything orther than a waste of a wage

They're pretty good, but not outstanding imo. I can see us nicking an equaliser.

Philips should be no where near the squad…so poor

Styles worked niffing wrong there…..complete t**t

Ref is a bit of a homer- giving every 50/50 the baggies way

Goodrham elbowed in the face. Ref doesn’t care. Helik slightly nudges a West Brom player - ref is fuming

FFS
That was embarrassing!
I never see the point in keepers going up, but then leaving a player out deep.
1-0 - game looks tight
2-0 - comfortable win

Phillips and Bennett are done with the professional game. It's better that realisation doesn't happen when a player is at your club.

if Phillips gets to start, what thefuck is he doing in training to warrant it, more to the point what thefuck is happening in training?

I don’t think the concern is that we are losing games away at West Brom it’s how we are losing. At no point today did we offer a threat and we are incredibly toothless.

Now to GR.
He for me, sits, for far too long in the dug out whilst WBA's Tony the Mowbray stood urging his side on all game long just like Mousinho did last week and do you know what, it works Rowett!

To me, players do respond to seeing a manager urging the side on - but just like Des did in his latter days with his continuous use of the bench seat it does seem that when the chips are down head for the safety of the bench!

Now to TM.
It was incredible to see this 60 + geezer who has battled back from a wicked disease put in a full 90 minute shift on the touchline and maybe a few people within our club may now just step up to the plate and emulate his determination.

Wasn't up to much today. I didn't think WBA were particularly good tbh, and they did wobble a bit when we finally ran at them last ten minutes.

IMO we were outclassed today. West Brom's midfield dominated ours, and they always seemed to have an extra man whichever side they attacked.
I think that's probably it for Phillips. He was undeniably poor, but the fanbase's reaction to him going off makes it hard to see a way back. The booing and cheering was unnecessary and immature, but also unsurprising.

We didn’t even give that a go today. We sat there and had our tummy tickled. They literally took the p**s.

Just got back home not a bad day out in West Brom the vine pub was excellent and food onto the football atm we haven't got a goal in the team thier goalie could have put the deck chair out that will be the easiest game he will have and we are sleep walking into relegation some how Rowett needs to get a tune out of these and quick but don't know how he will do it though. I think we should have had a stone wall penalty for handball going to have to watch that back.

struggle to think of a time we last booed one of our own players like Phillips got today. I was in the middle of sending a text when it happened and it caught me off guard

He was rightly booed because his first instinct was to clap the home fans and then us. I don't want to see him in an Oxford shirt again.

My granny would offer more than Phillips.

The absolute state of this forum today.
Those f*cking Firesticks have a lot to answer for

Albion possibly the most physical and quick side we,be played this season but thought they lacked flair. Typical Mowbray outfit.
When we get near their goal, for god’s sake pull the trigger.
Phillips was appalling, he played like an Albion special agent.
Even worse was the inept ref; a man who got in the way of passing movements twice and generally acted like a Black Country based competition winner. Take his licence away.

We were undoubtedly second best today but I didn't see a huge gulf in class between us which has to be taken as a huge positive. We are still building and improving whilst the baggies are stuck in nowhereland with there being little point of promotion given what happens.

Errrr....getting promoted to the Premier League, even if you go right back down with an embarrassing point total (like Southampton are seemingly doing) is worth about £140m to a club that's not currently getting parachute payments.
I reckon West Brom would view that as being a pretty good reason to get promoted!
(not that I think they will - they're clearly a class below Burnley/Sheffield United/Sunderland, and they'd likely have to beat two of them back-to-back to win the playoffs.....if they do even get there)

Good club, great stadium. Up there with Burnley as one of my favourites this season. The less said about Phillips the better, but my only real criticism of Rowett is the fact he keeps picking him. I don't expect we'll see him start again any time soon. Biggest difference between us and these top championship sides is movement. They constantly had options when on the ball and pressed us brilliantly off it. Looks like they copied the Burnley blueprint in terms of how to get at us, and like Burnley it should have been more comfortable for them.

Don't agree with the booing of our own player (probably aggravated by the over the top clapping of the Brom fans) but wow Phillips was bad today wasn't he? Was put on the wing with Bennett behind him so they could double up on Fellows who then proceeded to rinse them both multiple times, then got put up top to try and make it stick and win some headers and I don't think he won a single header. Just awful, probably one of our highest paid players and he really has been non league standard this seaso. Not sharp enough and devoid of creativity. Hopefully that's it for him now.

At the beginning of the season I guessed WBA had a good team. That was confirmed in October when United got a rather fortuitous draw against them. It was re-affirmed yesterday when the U's were outplayed. Surprisingly, WBA are not candidates for automatic promotion. They should be. From what I have seen they are better than Sunderland and may even be on a par with Sheffield United. Only Leeds stand ahead of them in my book.
But they have drawn too many games and are currently playing Ducks and Drakes with the lower play-off positions. I'm convinced they are much better than the teams currently around them in the table. They were certainly much too good for United yesterday. Their superiority revolved around their midfield trio of Mowatt, Molumby and Price. All quick, forward-looking and thinking players who mastered United's trio of Brannagan, Matos and Goodrham and denied them time on the ball.
WBA's central domination caused no little concern for United's back line. They stood up to it pretty well. But WBA knew what they were doing. Directing many attacks through the centre meant United closed up with the FBs supporting the CBs as they should. That left Johnson and Fellows free on the wings.
Somehow, United stayed in the game. It was a spirited performance but little else. Even the grandstand finish petered out when Bennett went off injured leaving the team with 10 men. With 5 substitutes available to use that should never happen to any team. With just 10 on the field and Cumming also up for a corner, WBA's second goal was literally the last kick of the game.
Referee was dreadful with some strange (wrong!) decisions throughout the game. The big one I recall is when he got in Brannagan's way - the latter having clear possession - allowing WBA to break away and "score." He initially allowed play to continue until the home team reached the penalty area before calling it back. There were no complaints from the home players.
There was also talk of a possible United penalty near the end. Brannagan's shot was blocked and the defender's arms and legs were stretched wide. I cannot say, however, if the ball actually hit the arm or vice-versa. Clearly, the referee didn't either.

Cumming’s save from Mowatt second half strike was a worldie

Really enjoy reading this thread and look forward to it each week. Thank you for doing this. Phillips getting some stick but we all knew his time was up some while back. Did think they may have had a shout for a penalty as did we so even stevens on that point.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: The View from the Opposition - Oxford United - by Leicesterbaggie - 02-23-2025, 06:31 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: