01-23-2025, 06:01 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-23-2025, 06:11 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
Because Germany, Italy and France have serious economic failings and should not be used as a benchmark for the UK if we actually want a strong economy. A far cry from Denmark or Spain though, would much rather they were the benchmark as their economies are doing quite well.
And I brought up the LSE study because that is what the FT article you referred to was reporting on, and in spite of your assertion it explicitly says the cost is billions of pounds on just goods thanks to red tape.
And those studies are trying to quantify a known effect, introducing massive amounts of NTBs on the largest source of imports and exports obvious to anyone with a brain and that's exactly what Brexit has done - the greatest act of British protectionism since the Tariff Reform League. The fact that you're championing a study that says the cost of Brexit is already billions as an endorsement of Brexit on the basis that larger companies have utilised their economies of scale to mitigate some aspects as well as delays on critical sectors says it all to be honest.
The context is that Germany is undergoing an industrial crisis because of stupid energy policy, France is undergoing a crisis because it has a serious structural deficit and sets itself on fire every time somebody tries to fix that and Italy has an average age of about 150 now. They're not healthy economies, but because they aren't people who bought into the stupidity that is Brexit are now selectively using them as though they're the entire EU to pretend that Brexit isn't the stupid mistake it actually is and pretend that the UK isn't in a group of four with those countries with very weak economic foundations that closer cooperation on investment to address some of those fundamental problems would massively help.
And I brought up the LSE study because that is what the FT article you referred to was reporting on, and in spite of your assertion it explicitly says the cost is billions of pounds on just goods thanks to red tape.
And those studies are trying to quantify a known effect, introducing massive amounts of NTBs on the largest source of imports and exports obvious to anyone with a brain and that's exactly what Brexit has done - the greatest act of British protectionism since the Tariff Reform League. The fact that you're championing a study that says the cost of Brexit is already billions as an endorsement of Brexit on the basis that larger companies have utilised their economies of scale to mitigate some aspects as well as delays on critical sectors says it all to be honest.
(01-23-2025, 05:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You'll probably need to put some context on that with base figures and time periods. Also don't forget that France, Germany and Italy will also have taken a hit with Brexit, they will have had extra costs put on exports to us, it isn't one way. And also if your argument is that we were forced to go and find new markets, then that could have happened in or out of the EU.
The context is that Germany is undergoing an industrial crisis because of stupid energy policy, France is undergoing a crisis because it has a serious structural deficit and sets itself on fire every time somebody tries to fix that and Italy has an average age of about 150 now. They're not healthy economies, but because they aren't people who bought into the stupidity that is Brexit are now selectively using them as though they're the entire EU to pretend that Brexit isn't the stupid mistake it actually is and pretend that the UK isn't in a group of four with those countries with very weak economic foundations that closer cooperation on investment to address some of those fundamental problems would massively help.


