05-23-2019, 07:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-23-2019, 07:27 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
I also want to point out, as we're on the topic of the steel industry, due to how old our steel manufacturing infrastructure is and how isolated the furnaces are compared with the Chinese nationalising the industry would be a massive money pit unless the government puts tens of billions towards modernising the industry. At which point they may as well put that money into railway infrastructure as that's more critical and would provide more cash for the treasury long term.
No, that isn't at all what happened. The EU deployed a carbon tax a couple of years back on international steel imports from 3rd countries in response to steel tariffs from other countries that were applied to EU steel in other countries giving others an unfair advantage. This levy is based on annual production, the extension for Article 50 doesn't run till the new year so it would have just been delayed for a few months until we are officially seen as a 3rd country (we also voluntarily dropped our premiership of the Council and relinquished our veto on trade agreements shortly after we notified the EU that we signed Article 50). As per the terms set out in the extension the UK government decided not pursue a delay on the levy being charged, TATA steel/British Steel were not subject to the levy for 2017 and 2018.
As for nationalisation rules in the EU, we are allowed to part nationalise industry by taking a controlling stake into the company as a shareholder. We opted not to. What we are not allowed to do is literally "seize the means of production" so that we are obliged to pay market rates and allow private firms the opportunity to outbid us if they wish. We did that with Network Rail.
(05-23-2019, 07:10 PM)Sotv Wrote:(05-23-2019, 07:03 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:(05-23-2019, 12:31 PM)Sotv Wrote:(05-23-2019, 12:25 PM)col lard Wrote: I wonder how many of the Scunthorpe steel workers voted Leave? Chickens coming home to roost,eh?
yes, given that the EU put rules in place that do not permit national governements to bail out industries i'm sure you are correct in identifying Brexit as the reason for the the closure of British steel.
Do you think that its your kind of ill informed, smug remarks that imply people deserve to lose their jobs for voting in referendum that makes many leavers think a lot of remainers are truly scum
What caused the collapse of British Steel was the Chinese dumping steel to artificially lower the price and 13 governments of the EU, one of which was the UK, vetoing a bill set out by the commission to counter that. On top of a renown asset stripper taking over the remnants of British Steel from TATA with the intention of using the government as leverage or else wind down operations.
Oh, and the company being subject to a carbon levy from the EU which they would have been exempt from had we not activated Article 50.
So basically the EU imposed the carbon levy before we have left as some form of punishment for voting to leave and you wonder why some people call it an autocratic bully?
You are correct about steel dumping yet other countries steel industries survive, why? Because they have state intervention to protect industries (not something I agree with but it’s undeniable that Soubry used EU rules as an excuse for not giving them help a few years back)
No, that isn't at all what happened. The EU deployed a carbon tax a couple of years back on international steel imports from 3rd countries in response to steel tariffs from other countries that were applied to EU steel in other countries giving others an unfair advantage. This levy is based on annual production, the extension for Article 50 doesn't run till the new year so it would have just been delayed for a few months until we are officially seen as a 3rd country (we also voluntarily dropped our premiership of the Council and relinquished our veto on trade agreements shortly after we notified the EU that we signed Article 50). As per the terms set out in the extension the UK government decided not pursue a delay on the levy being charged, TATA steel/British Steel were not subject to the levy for 2017 and 2018.
As for nationalisation rules in the EU, we are allowed to part nationalise industry by taking a controlling stake into the company as a shareholder. We opted not to. What we are not allowed to do is literally "seize the means of production" so that we are obliged to pay market rates and allow private firms the opportunity to outbid us if they wish. We did that with Network Rail.

