12-18-2024, 02:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 04:30 PM by ericlegrisly.)
(12-18-2024, 11:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Still 55% of the season to go. It's still fair too early to judge.
Heggem is clearly a success. I'm pretty sure Styles will be, too.
We all know what Johnston is capable of, so I won't be told that's a poor signing, because absolutely no one questioned it at the time. In fact - it was the opposite. Everyone was buzzing. Ditto Holgate. So that's 4 signings right off the bat I would deem good and sensible.
With regards to Racic, Diakite, and Cole. They've not really figured much, but I've seen glimpses in their play to suggest each one could be a good or solid player given a run of games to allow them to get up to speed. But they simply need more time to judge.
Dobbins, jury is very much out.
Frabotta - bizarre. Good CV, but has seemingly been frozen out.
In summary, too early to judge. 4 good signings, 3 signings where you need more opportunity to judge. 2 apparent busts, but similarly they need more opportunity.
Also, I seem to recall most reasonable people agreed we had an excellent summer, transfer business wise. I still believe that to be the case.
Ahem. I certainly did.
As for the rest:
Racic - No. Too ponderous, not good enough.
Styles - Yes. Done OK.
Frabotta - I think I share Corberan's reservations.
Dobbins - Shit
Diakite - Not good enough
Heggem - Yes.
Cole - No idea.
Should point out I'm not moaning about this - we find ourselves where we are and gamble signings are a bit of a necessity. They were never likely to all come off.

