(12-10-2024, 08:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:(12-10-2024, 06:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:Oh, pack it in, lad(12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?Compare this to Bartley who rarely if ever makes a basic error.
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions
He's had a good season so far, but this is not correct at all!
I haven't said he doesn't make errors. He just doesn't make many if any really basic, fundamental defensive mistakes.
9/10 he is in the right spot, makes the appropriate movements, marks his man effectively, heads things clear, makes sensible decisions when in possession.
All the basics for a defender that both Semi and Holgate don't do anywhere near consistently enough. Both of whom have much better "attributes" than Bart's. Semi has the physicality to be a top defender, Holgate has good agility and technical ability, but neither have a natural, high level defensive IQ.
"IMO of course..."



